The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
Romanticism is at bottom a sigh for the things that perish, and the
things that can never happen again. It is like the soldier going over
the hill to fight, but always looking back and lingering. The things
that Time destroys we love with a love fed by romantic regret--the
sunset that will never just happen again, the snows of yester-year, the
beliefs that are being sapped, the days of our own childhood. In _The
Cloister and the Hearth_, Gerard at the beginning of his wanderings
is kindly treated by a woman and her husband; as he leaves them they
wish him “God speed,” and, says the author, “with that they parted,
and never met again in this world”; and nobody can read that sentence
without loving these people more. If some novelists had described this
incident, if, say Dickens had been writing this, it would have been
part of his way of working, it would have been in keeping with his
avowed theories of life, to renew the connection between Gerard and
his kind acquaintances later in life, and by some coincidence to make
the good woman and her husband turn up when we had forgotten their
existence. But Reade not only declines to do this, he goes out of his
way, beforehand, to tell us that he is not going to do this; he makes
these people pass out into the darkness and so he leaves us with a
feeling of affectionate regret for them. When we know a thing must
die, something comes to reinforce our love for it, and if we were all
told to take our last look upon this earth to-morrow, what worst of
world-haters would not ask again and again for “just one peep more”?
Universal literature is full of regrets for all the lovely things
that die. All history is full of movements that are born of romantic
reactions--of prophets stoned on one day and mourned the next, of
rejected leaders idolised when they have passed off the stage and soon
carried to power again by a mad romantic impulse that moves the people,
of kings beheaded and then loved when they have become a memory, of
Restorations, of returns from Elba, and of Jacobite risings. Every
generation cries that the world is going to the dogs and that things
are not as they have been, and two years before the Spanish Armada was
routed an Englishman could complain that English courage was on the
wane. All this is romanticism; and it is romanticism that makes old
men gather round a chimney-corner to tell a tale of old times, and
makes hardened heroes love to fight their battles over again. It is
this feeling that sends us treading again the haunts of childhood and
recapturing childhood scenes; that makes our imagination play around
historic sites and ancient buildings, peopling them with a life that we
have invented, and awaking them to their former activeness; and that so
thrills the heart with a sense of the great bygone things, that some
men cannot see the sun go down red without dreaming of battles long
ago, till the moors become alive with excited horsemen and with noises
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account