The History of Philosophy in IslamBoer, T. J. de (Tjitze J.)
Islamic
The History of Philosophy in Islam
Boer, T. J. de (Tjitze J.)
Islamic philosophy -- History
2. An assertion, expressed in logical or dialectic fashion, whether
verbal or written, was called by the Arabs,—generally, but more
particularly in religious teaching—a Kalam (λόγος), and those who
advanced such assertions were called Mutakallimun. The name was
transferred from the individual assertion to the entire system, and it
covered also the introductory, elementary observations on Method,—and
so on. Our best designation for the science of the Kalam is
‘Theological Dialectics’ or simply ‘Dialectics’; and in what follows we
may translate Mutakallimun by ‘Dialecticians’.
The name Mutakallimun, which was at first common to all the
Dialecticians, was in later times applied specially to the
Antimutazilite and Orthodox theologians. In the latter case it might be
well, following the sense, to render the term by Dogmatists or
Schoolmen. In fact while the first dialecticians had the Dogma still to
form, those who came later had only to expound and establish it.
The introduction of Dialectics into Islam was a violent innovation, and
it was vehemently denounced by the party of the Tradition. Whatever
went beyond the regular ethical teaching was heresy to them, for faith
should be obedience, and not,—as was maintained by the Murdjites and
Mutazilites—, knowledge. By the latter it was laid down without reserve
that speculation was one of the duties of believers. Even to this
demand the times became reconciled, for according to tradition the
Prophet had said already: ‘The first thing which God created was
Knowledge or Reason’.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account