The History of Philosophy in IslamBoer, T. J. de (Tjitze J.)
Islamic
The History of Philosophy in Islam
Boer, T. J. de (Tjitze J.)
Islamic philosophy -- History
The ancients had prepared the way for this conception by their theory,
amongst other things, of the discontinuous character of Number. Was not
Time defined as the tale or numbering of Motion? Why should we not
apply that doctrine to Space, Time and Motion? The Dialecticians did
this; and the ‘skepsis’ of the older philosophy may have contributed
its influence in the process. Like the substantial, corporeal
world,—Space, Time and Motion were decomposed into atoms devoid of
extension, and into moments without duration. Time becomes a succession
of many individual ‘Nows’, and between every two moments of time there
is a void. The same is the case with Motion: between every two
movements there is a Rest. A quick motion and a slow motion possess the
same speed, but the latter has more points of Rest. Then, in order to
get over the difficulty of the empty space, the unoccupied moment of
time, and the pause for rest between two movements, the theory of a
Leap is made use of. Motion is to be regarded as a leaping onward from
one point in space to another, and Time as an advance effected in the
same manner from one moment to another.
In reality they had no use at all for this fantastic theory of a Leap:
it was a mere reply to unsophisticated questioning. With perfect
consistency they had cut up the entire material world, as it moves in
space and time, into Atoms with their Accidents. Some no doubt
maintained, that although accidents every moment disappear, yet
substances endure, but others made no difference in this respect. They
taught that substances, which are in fact points in space, exist only
for a point of time, just like Accidents. Every moment God creates the
world anew, so that its condition at the present moment has no
essential connection with that which has immediately preceded it or
that which follows next. In this way there is a series of worlds
following one another, which merely present the appearance of one
world. That for us there is anything like connection or Causality in
phenomena proceeds from the fact that Allah in his inscrutable will
does not choose either to-day or to-morrow to interrupt the usual
course of events by a miracle,—which however he is able at any moment
to do. The disappearance of all causal connection according to the
Atomistic Kalam is vividly illustrated by the classical instance of
‘the writing man.’ God creates in him,—and that too by an act of
creation which is every moment renewed—first the will, then the faculty
of writing, next the movement of the hand, and lastly the motion of the
pen. Here one thing is completely independent of the other.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account