The History of the Manners and Customs of Ancient Greece, Volume 1 (of 3)St. John, James Augustus
History
The History of the Manners and Customs of Ancient Greece, Volume 1 (of 3)
St. John, James Augustus
Greece -- Social life and customs
Winkelmann, who on so many questions connected with art has put
forward opinions highly just and philosophical, appears to have fallen
short of his wonted acumen in the theory he had formed of the beauty
of the goddesses. His language in fact descends to puerility where he
says:—"Since on the subject of female beauty there are few
observations to be made, it may be concluded that the study of it is
less complicated and far easier for the artist. Nature itself appears
to experience less difficulty in the formation of women than of men,
_if it be true_ that there are born fewer boys than girls."[969] Since
the direct contrary is true, this imaginary difficulty of Nature (not
to hazard a more sacred word) may be dismissed with contempt; but the
remark by which it is ushered in requires to be confuted. Artists are
well aware, and Winkelmann himself admits, that the beau ideal of
heroic beauty (that for example of Achilles or of Theseus) is merely
the blending of feminine loveliness with masculine power, so as to
leave it undetermined, from the countenance, to which sex it belongs.
And still the beauty of the Grecian youth, where they are beautiful,
consists in a near approach to that of the female, so near indeed that
they might be easily mistaken for women. If, therefore, the beauty of
men when highest and most perfect, consists chiefly in what it borrows
from that of woman, the latter necessarily constitutes the apex of
human beauty; and the artist whom this conviction guides in his
creations, will be the first to rival the great masters of antiquity.
Another observation which it is strange to find in the Historian of
Art, is that artists draped their female figures because of the little
difficulty there is in imitating the naked form. But was it the
extreme facility of representing paternal grief that led Timanthes to
veil the face of his Agamemnon? In draping their goddesses and
heroines, artists were guided by other reasons, of which the principal
was their desire to conform to the ideas of the poets and to popular
belief.
Footnote 969:
Hist. de l’Art, iv. 2. 67.
CHAPTER X.
HELLENIC LITERATURE.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account