The history of the psychoanalytic movementFreud, Sigmund
History
The history of the psychoanalytic movement
Freud, Sigmund
Psychoanalysis -- History
Perhaps in many respects it might have been better had I permitted free
vent to my own passions and to those about me. We have all heard the
interesting attempt at an explanation of the origin of psychoanalysis
from its Viennese milieu. Janet did not scorn to make use of it as late
as 1913, although, no doubt, he is proud of being a Parisian. This
_aperçu_ says that psychoanalysis, especially the assertion that the
neuroses can be traced back to disturbances in the sexual life, could
only have originated in a city like Vienna, in an atmosphere of
sensuality and immorality not to be found in other cities, and that it
thus represents only a reflection, the theoretical projection as it
were, of these particular Viennese conditions. Well, I certainly am no
local patriot, but this theory has always seemed to be especially
nonsensical, so nonsensical that sometimes I was inclined to assume that
the reproaching of the Vienna spirit was only a euphemistic substitution
for another one which one did not care to bring up publicly. If the
assumptions had been of the opposite kind, we might be inclined to
listen. But even if we assume that there might be a city whose
inhabitants have imposed upon themselves special sexual restrictions and
at the same time show a peculiar tendency to severe neurotic maladies,
then such a town might well furnish the soil on which some observer
might get the idea of connecting these two facts and of deducting the
one from the other. But neither assumption fits Vienna. The Viennese are
neither more abstemious nor yet more nervous than dwellers in any other
metropolis. Sex matters are a little freer, prudishness is less than in
the cities of western and northern Europe that are so proud of their
chastity. Our supposed observer would, more likely, be led astray by the
particular conditions prevailing in Vienna than be enlightened as to the
cause of the neuroses.
But Vienna has done everything possible to deny her share in the origin
of psychoanalysis. Nowhere else is the inimical indifference of the
learned and cultured circles so clearly evident to the psychoanalyst.
Perhaps I am somewhat to blame for this by my policy of avoiding
widespread publicity. If I had caused psychoanalysis to occupy the
medical societies of Vienna with noisy sessions, with an unloading of
all passions, wherein all reproaches and invectives carried on the
tongue or in the mind would have been expressed, then perhaps the ban
against psychoanalysis might, by now, have been removed and its standing
no longer might have been that of a stranger in its native city. As it
is, the poet may be right when he makes Wallenstein say:
“Yet this the Viennese will not forgive me,
That I did them out of a spectacle.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account