The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 2, October, 1909Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 2, October, 1909
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
The point on which the report lays greatest stress, namely, the
necessity of teaching Government as a distinct subject in the secondary
schools, was expressly approved by the association without a dissenting
vote. It does not follow, of course, that the report expresses the
views of every member of that association, in every particular. In
fact it does not. The report does represent the views of the entire
committee after making an exhaustive study of the question.
The report covers 38 pages of the proceedings, and is therefore too
elaborate to be properly presented in a brief article. Only a few of
the essential features will be referred to.
At the very outset the committee was confronted with the pedagogical
question as to whether Government should be taught as a distinct
subject or whether it should be taught in connection with history.
The teachers are still somewhat divided on the subject, and practice
varies. The information collected indicates that the teaching of
American Government, Civil Government or Civics as it is still
barbarously designated, is suffering from a lack of proper recognition
in the school curriculum, for want of especially trained teachers, from
lack of a working school library on Government and from inadequate
text-books. It seems a curious thing that our public schools, which
were instituted and are operated by governmental agency to maintain
an enlightened citizenship, have taught every other subject excepting
Government. There can be little doubt that the rather confused and
contradictory recommendations of the Committee of Seven ten years ago
helped materially to spread the impression among high school teachers
that the subject of Government could not be successfully studied
apart from History, and that it is a sort of poor relation to it on
which little time need be spent. The suggestion of the Committee of
Seven that the subject might be taught in connection with American
History was adopted by a large number of schools. The results obtained
are generally considered to be unsatisfactory. In the West out of
240 schools heard from, 153 were offering separate instruction in
Government, 47 taught the subject in connection with History, and 40
failed to specify the plan in use. The teachers or principals in these
schools personally preferred the separate course by 158 to 30, 54
failing to commit themselves.
In the South 85 schools reported a separate course in Government, 53 a
combination course with History. The teachers or principals reporting
preferred the separate course by 111 to 33.
In the East and Mid-West 98 schools reported a separate course on
Government and 74 a combination course. The teachers or principals
expressed a personal preference for the separate course by 110 to 42.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account