The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
This condition may be variously explained. The trouble is often caused
by an improper use of the text-book, the incompetent teacher resting
content if the pupil commits the words on the pages and recites them
with some semblance of intelligence. In most cases, however, it is safe
to say that the misconceptions are the result of the teacher’s failure
to grasp the child’s difficulties, his inability to put himself into
the pupil’s place and realize the mental equipment which the child
brings to the grasping of the new ideas. Be the cause of the difficulty
what it may, the recognition of its existence must be the first step
toward its removal.
The word “claim” occupies a prominent place among the disturbers of
the peace. In the course of the history work the children become
familiar with the fact that the voyages and explorations of the
Spanish, English, French and Dutch somehow give rise to “land claims”
whose overlapping results in interesting international conflicts.
Judicious questioning, however, is apt to disclose a surprising lack
of definiteness as to the meaning of this word “claim.” In accordance
with the type-lesson method this vagueness of comprehension might
readily be avoided if the “claim” concept were developed thoroughly in
connection with the explorations of a single European nation. In other
words, the teaching of a typical claim forms the surest sort of basis
for the comprehension of land claims in general. Spain, because of the
early date of its explorations, naturally suggests itself as the type.
Let the pupil understand intensively all that we can teach him about
the Spanish claim--how far it extended, on what it was based, what it
meant--and there will be no difficulty when we come to develop the
claims of England, France and Holland.
In presenting the type lesson on the Spanish claim the teacher must
carefully distinguish and strongly emphasize the type-elements, _i.
e._, those aspects of the subject which help form a clear concept
or pattern. Chief among these type-elements may be mentioned the
following: A clear understanding of what we mean by “right of
discovery;” some notion of the distance a claim may be said to extend
beyond the point or coast explored; a definite comprehension of what
is meant when we speak of a nation “owning” land; a mental attitude
toward the rights of the original inhabitants. Reference to these
fundamentals will have to be made repeatedly when the claims of
other European nations are in their turn presented to the class, but
this mere reference is all that will be required if the type-elements
developed in connection with the Spanish claim have been thoroughly
grounded. The particular incidents of the Spanish story, pedagogically
speaking, are of less fundamental significance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account