The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
It may be a matter of surprise that a paper devoted largely to the
interests of teachers of history in secondary schools and colleges
should print in one number nearly five pages of matter relating to
history in elementary schools. Yet there should be no need of an
apology. Were not the several parts of the American educational system
so independent of one another, our secondary and college teachers of
history would not pride themselves upon their ignorance of conditions
in the elementary schools. Because organically or politically there
is little correlation among the three parts of the system, each part
attempts to ignore the others, rejecting suggestions concerning its
own work, and grudgingly and condescendingly giving advice concerning
the others. With a few notable exceptions, several of whom appear as
contributors to this number of the MAGAZINE, college men in America
have kept sedulously away from the problems of history teaching in the
elementary school, or if they have turned their gaze upon the schools,
it has been to seek a market for a new elementary history textbook.
Yet the elementary school needs the best thought that the nation can
give to it; not the thought of elementary school men alone, but the
clearness and directness and thoroughness which come so frequently
with college training. It is superciliousness or inertia which leads a
college instructor to say that he cannot realize the problems of the
elementary school, and then to send his children to a class taught by a
young girl fresh from the normal school or high school. It was not thus
that the schedules for history in the Prussian or French schools were
made. It is not by thus leaving the determination of policy to weaker
employees that great corporations succeed. And how much more valuable
are our children than corporate wealth!
The report of the Committee of Eight is beyond doubt the most important
feature of the year in the teaching of history in America. It deserves
to rank with the report of the Committee of Seven, and its influence
may well be even greater. The report is remarkable for its sanity, its
absence of theorizing, its understanding of the mind of the child at
several ages, its clearness and general helpfulness. Not content with
merely outlining the field of history for each grade, the committee
has realized the weakness of the teacher, and has constructed a course
of study for her, and has even gone so far as to advise the emphasis
and amount of time to be given to each subject. Schedule-makers have
previously had no advice from historians upon these points; they have
been left severely alone to fix their days and hours and subjects as
they might think best. The report changes all this by combining the
scholarly knowledge of the historian with the skill of the pedagogical
student and with the worldly wisdom of the schedule maker.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account