The Hospital Bulletin, Vol. V, No. 2, April 15, 1909Various
Philosophy
The Hospital Bulletin, Vol. V, No. 2, April 15, 1909
Various
Medical colleges -- Alumni and alumnae -- Maryland -- Baltimore -- Periodicals; Medicine -- Periodicals
It may be somewhat out of place in a paper dealing with "The Ethics of
the General Practitioner" to speak of the tendency, or perhaps better,
the half-formed determination of the majority of every class to be
specialists. I must confine myself to the predilection of the average
medical student for surgery. It was so in my day, and I suppose it is so
now, that almost 75 per cent. of the graduating classes are thoroughly
satisfied that the end and aim of medicine is surgery; that practice and
the less spectacular branches are parts of the profession essential to
it as a whole, and fitted for those who intend to lead the plodding
life, but too slow and too prosaic for the man bursting with the
knowledge of his own brilliancy and his own special fitness. There is no
question but that this tendency has done much to lower the average
fitness of many classes. Men become listless and careless, neglecting
everything but their hobby, and while the surgical amphitheatre is
crowded, the medical clinics will be shunned, even deserted were it not
that the sections are such that the absentees can be spotted and warned.
There is no question also but that indifference to everything but
surgery is responsible for many of the failures before the State
Examining Boards. We must have surgeons, and they must begin their
training in medical schools, and it is not my purpose to discourage
earnest work and honest effort to this end. I wish, however, to say that
every ethical specialist needs a thorough grounding in the general
branches of medicine, and he should not in his student days neglect the
other essentials to a well-rounded man. Most heartily do I wish to
condemn the careless, happy-go-lucky manner in which so many men totally
unprepared and totally unsuited by temperament for this branch "rush in
where angels fear to tread." I wish especially to draw your attention to
the fact that there is a vast difference between the operator and the
surgeon. Almost any young man with a disregard of the sight of blood,
with nerves unaffected by human suffering and a heart untouched by a
knowledge of his power to do harm, can in six months' practice on the
cadaver learn to cut, to sew and to ligate with neatness and despatch.
Indeed, there may be many before me of the student body whose young and
nimble fingers could teach dexterity to the best surgeons of the city.
Very many with no pretense to this dexterity, and no equipment but a
superabundance of assurance, graduate as surgeons and assume and aspire
to a position of prominence that it has taken the true surgeon years of
the hardest, closest, most untiring study, observation and work to
reach. We are told as an excuse for this remarkable evolution from the
student to the surgeon that the young man of today is taught so much
more than the old men were; that the very manner of teaching, the
equipment of the schools and the superior requirements for matriculation
cannot but turn out better posted and more competent men.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account