The Hospital Bulletin, Vol. V, No. 2, April 15, 1909 — John Shaqi
The Hospital Bulletin, Vol. V, No. 2, April 15, 1909Various
Philosophy
The Hospital Bulletin, Vol. V, No. 2, April 15, 1909
Various
Medical colleges -- Alumni and alumnae -- Maryland -- Baltimore -- Periodicals; Medicine -- Periodicals
There has been no greater shame in our profession than the influence
these men and their houses have exercised, and incidentally the
indorsements and recommendations that thoughtless men have furnished
them. The blame is all ours, and we cannot shun it. We pride ourselves
on our scientific attainments; that we take nothing for granted; and,
now that the age of empiricism has passed, we accept nothing that does
not bear the stamp of scientific approval. And yet, before the campaign
of the American Medical Association and the revelations of Collier's and
the Ladies' Home Journal, we accepted our treatment from the hands of
the manufacturing houses, and dosed our patients with nostrums about
which we knew nothing except the statements of those whose sole purpose
it was to sell. There are few of us who have been many years in practice
to whom a blush of shame does not come at the recollection of our
gullibility and our guilty innocence. Can any man deem it ethical to
give even to a good dog something about which he was totally ignorant?
And yet this is just what we were doing. A short time ago a particularly
shrewd detail man was discussing this very point with me, and claiming
that, as the formula was now required by law to be printed in each
bottle and package, this most formidable objection could not now hold
good. Handing me a bottle of his patent cure-all, he glibly called my
attention to the six or seven ingredients, with the amount of each
contained in the fluid ounce. Among other potent quantities I can recall
1-48 gr. of morphia and 1-240 gr. of strychnia. The dose was a
teaspoonful three times a day. Any man can imagine the more than
homeopathic effect of 1-48 gr. of morphia divided into eight doses.
These well-known and well-tried drugs were not, however, the life of the
nostrum, and presently we came to the twenty minims to the fluid ounce
of the fluid extract of the drug from which the remedy derived its name.
Something I had never heard of. Something unlisted in the U. S. P.
Something discovered and owned and controlled by this house alone. As my
ignorance became more apparent his eloquence increased, and I have no
doubt that a few years ago, before my moral conscience had become
aroused to the therapeutic sin of prescribing something whose botanical
family, whose chemical formula, and even whose physiological effects
were totally unknown to me, I would gladly have accepted a sample and
would have tried it on some poor soul too poor to pay for a
prescription. It is nothing short of a shame to think of what we have
done in this line. The sin has been one of carelessness and laziness
rather than of ignorance. Here we had ready to hand some remedy,
beautiful to the eye, palatable to the tongue; then why take the time
and trouble to bother about constructing a formula of our own when
someone else of equal experience had constructed one for us? I am ready
to thank God that most of these nostrums are as harmless as they are
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account