The Hunterian lectures on colour-vision and colour-blindness — John Shaqi
The Hunterian lectures on colour-vision and colour-blindnessEdridge-Green, F. W. (Frederick William)
Science
The Hunterian lectures on colour-vision and colour-blindness
Edridge-Green, F. W. (Frederick William)
Color blindness
II. _The requirements of a test for colour-blindness._--A test for
colour-blindness, when it is to be employed for some definite and
specific purpose, as, for instance, excluding dangerous persons from
certain callings, should be such as to show definitely that the
persons rejected are dangerous. It is very useful to demonstrate to
the men and their fellows that a rejected candidate is dangerous. The
colleagues of a rejected candidate would refuse to risk their lives
with a man who before their eyes called a red light, green. I was
expressing these views when a superintendent of a railway company,
who is using my lamp, told me that he had adopted this method with
great satisfaction to himself and to the men. A man, for instance, who
has been working twenty years on the railway has been rejected for
colour-blindness. He has complained bitterly to the superintendent,
at the same time declaring emphatically that he is normal-sighted.
The superintendent has replied, “You know red?”--“Yes.” “You know
green?”--“Yes.” “You will therefore agree that if you call green,
red; or red, green, you ought to be rejected. Bring two or three of
the other men in with you and I will test you.” The man has readily
agreed to this. The superintendent has then tested him by asking him to
name various coloured objects in the room, and knowing by experience
exactly the coloured objects which are miscalled by the colour-blind
readily exposes his defect. It is noteworthy that on some occasions a
colour-blind man has been tested by another person in the same room
without making any of the mistakes which he subsequently made, because
none but coloured objects which he could readily recognise were shown
to him. This is an example of the necessity of a practical knowledge
of colour-blindness in an examiner. On account of the arrangement of
signals by sea and land, it is necessary that persons employed in the
marine and railway services should be able to recognise and distinguish
between the standard red, green, and white lights in all conditions
in which they are likely to be placed. An engine-driver or sailor has
to name a coloured light when he sees it, not to match it. He has to
say to himself, “This is a red light, therefore there is danger”; and
this is practically the same as if he made the observation out loud.
Therefore, from the very commencement we have colour-names introduced,
and it is impossible to exclude them. The engine-driver is told that
red is a “danger” signal, green a “caution” signal, and white an “all
right” signal. Therefore, it is absolutely necessary that he should
know the meaning of these colour-names. A test should be such as to
make it impossible for the examinee to be coached through it. This is
one of the most important requirements of a test for colour-blindness
and one that is rarely fulfilled. Nearly every one of the tests in
general use fail on this account.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account