The Incarnate Purpose: Essays on the Spiritual Unity of LifePercival, G. H.
Religion
The Incarnate Purpose: Essays on the Spiritual Unity of Life
Percival, G. H.
Christianity; Spiritual life
But the inequality of species cannot be
adopted as the calculative basis of comparative
virtue in the evolutionary scale, since
the relative positions of organisms can only
be determined by an examination of the degree
of consciousness possessed by each in comparison
with the others. For instance, although
we say that a horse is a more highly organised
creature than a rabbit, meaning thereby that
according to our estimation he presents a more
complicated mechanism, yet such a comparison
of physical susceptibility is necessarily imperfect,
because limited by the degree of our own
discrimination. For since the correctness of our
judicial opinions rests upon our ability properly
to appreciate the true relation between intelligences
and their environments different from
our own, it follows that our criticism of their
comparative complexity can be no criterion of
intrinsic individual merit. The same inadequacy
of human judgment applies to any
attempt to estimate the degree of spiritual
consciousness possessed by various organisms.[28]
Such endeavour may be successful in establishing
a comparative standard for a rational
criticism of religious creeds in their relation to
physical evolution; but it is powerless to affix
a stationary standard of morality to differently
constructed intelligences.
The possession by creatures of faculties
differing from those of others does not necessarily
make for superiority or inferiority.
That is to say, differentiation of type does not
determine merit. A man is not superior to a
horse because his structure and powers are
unlike those of the horse; nor is a rabbit or a
bird inferior either to a horse or to a man,
since the organisation of all these creatures is
adapted to different usage. Thus, the possession
of a highly specialised brain does not in
itself make of man a superior order of creation.
The use or abuse of faculties, and the obedience
or disobedience to the laws of being, offer the
only standard by which the comparative
superiority, inferiority, or equality of creatures
of different organisation can be fairly estimated.[29]
And only by a similar comparison of the response
to spiritual environment displayed by
the followers of religious creeds can an approximate
idea of their value be formed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account