The Indian operation of couching for cataractElliot, Robert Henry
History
The Indian operation of couching for cataract
Elliot, Robert Henry
Cataract -- Surgery -- India; Ophthalmology -- India -- History
When thou hast remarked that, lower it carefully
and gently and slowly, so as not to disturb the cataract; but try and
free the matter entirely from the pupil and from the uvea with care,
and keep it intact. Press the said matter with the needle under it,
with the greatest care, and when thou perceivest that it is altogether
free and loose, draw and direct the needle, with the matter behind it,
upwards, and then pass it well downwards, behind the thin retina and
the aranea of the eye; and take care that it remains there.... This is
the recognised instruction, research, and indication of the means of
operating, of pricking the cataract, or of the manner in which such
an operation ought to be initiated and conducted. But no one ought to
undertake such an operation unless he has learnt much and seen much,
and unless he is fundamentally taught by intelligent doctors. Unless he
is so, it is not well to operate. And it is not wise to trust to any
of the brotherhood who happen to be dressed in velvet or silk, and who
boast of being great oculists, and are capable of curing the blind from
cataract. Certainly these can make holes in the eyes, but I do not know
how they can succeed.”
The knowledge which the Greeks and the Arabs possessed, before
and after the dawn of the Christian era, on the subject of the
pathology and treatment of cataract, appears to have been largely
forgotten during the Middle Ages. It would seem that both couching
and extraction fell into disuse, and that the surgical treatment of
cataract was left for centuries in the hands of wandering charlatans,
whose ways brought much discredit upon it. Towards the close of the
seventeenth century, Pierre Brisseau, a doctor of Tournay, revived
the operation, inventing a needle of his own for the purpose. His
advocacy of the method aroused bitter controversy, but it was
undoubtedly the best operation in the field until the famous French
surgeon Daviel performed his first extraction in 1745, and thus sounded
the death-knell of a procedure which had held the pride of place in
European surgery for over seventeen centuries. It was, however, many
years before couching was definitely abandoned in favour of extraction.
Indeed, the author has recently had the privilege of discussing this
subject with a distinguished surgeon, who can remember the time when
depression was still a recognised method of operating in London. It is
a great mistake to suppose that Daviel was the first to endeavour to
extract a cataract, for both extraction and suction of cataracts have
their roots far back in history. Indeed, Antyllus described his method
of extraction at the close of the first century of the Christian era,
and there are numerous other references to it in early literature. What
Daviel did was to adopt a technique which gave a reasonable prospect of
success.
[Illustration: Fig. 3.--Depression.]
[Illustration: Fig. 4.--Reclination.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account