The Indian operation of couching for cataract — John Shaqi
The Indian operation of couching for cataractElliot, Robert Henry
History
The Indian operation of couching for cataract
Elliot, Robert Henry
Cataract -- Surgery -- India; Ophthalmology -- India -- History
are yellow, some reddish-brown, some almost coal black, with every
intermediate shade between. It is possible that our investigations
failed for want of competent assistance with the spectroscopic analysis
of the lenses. An interesting field for research is here presented.
That deep-seated metabolic changes accompany the development of a
cataract has been shown by J. Burdon Cooper, and it seems not unlikely
that the apparent prevalence of lenticular opacities in tropical
countries may be closely bound up with the metabolic changes we have
described. It is probable that the retinal pigment layer is not the
only source of the deep discoloration of the lenses met with by
surgeons in India. A point in favour of the argument we have been
elaborating is that some years ago McHardy published the analysis by
MacMunn of the spectrum of the pigment obtained from a black cataract.
This was found to be quite distinct from blood-pigment, and to be
allied to the cell-pigment, which gives coloration to ectodermal
structures in animals (Trans. of the O.S. of the U.K., 1882).
To collect the 780 cases now under review has taken over twelve years,
and the writer is deeply indebted to Major Kirkpatrick for his great
generosity in allowing his 230 cases, the later ones of the series, to
be made use of in this paper. Throughout all these years one definite
purpose has been kept in the forefront--viz., to ascertain the real
value of lens couching. After making every possible allowance for the
vaidyan, the fact remains that he is a standing menace to society,
and that he should be suppressed. His methods are crude, filthy, and
dangerous; his results are so appalling that anyone unacquainted
with the ignorance and credulity of the Indian ryot would think it
impossible for him to continue to exist. His impudent lying includes
not merely a grossly exaggerated statement of his own successes, but
extends to the most barefaced falsehoods as to the nature of the
results obtained in European hospitals. It may be permissible to
quote one instance--unfortunately, far from a solitary one in Madras
experience. Some years ago a peasant, who had had a cataract removed
in the Government Ophthalmic Hospital, and whose recollections of
his treatment there were most kindly, returned for operation on the
second eye. On the steps of a temple, within a hundred yards from
our operating theatre, this man, who had travelled several hundred
miles for aid, was induced, by a tissue of impudent lies, to sit
down and submit to couching. A few days later he presented himself
at the out-patient room with panophthalmitis. There is no branch of
ophthalmic disease and treatment in India which so profoundly impresses
the Western surgeon’s imagination as this one. Remember that cataract
strikes a man down in his maturity, at a period of his life when he has
begun to reap the benefits of his earlier years of toilsome industry.
His pay and his home expenses are both alike at their maximum. He is
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account