The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
of the incandescent gases in the open hearth. It is from such facts so
construed that modern technology is made up, and it is by such channels
that the sense of workmanship has gone to the making of it.
So the question recurs, How has it come about that this pecuniary
culture--with its institutions drawn in terms of differential advantage
and moved by sentiments that converge on emulative gain and the
invidiously conspicuous waste of goods--has yet furthered the growth
of such a technology, even permissively? In its direct incidence, the
discipline of this pecuniary culture is doubtless inimical to any
advance in workmanlike insight or any matter-of-fact apprehension and
use of objective phenomena. It is a civilisation whose substantial
core is of a subjective kind, in the narrowly subjective, personal,
individualistic sense given by the self-regarding sentiments of
emulous rivalry.[113] But when all is said it is after all a peaceable
culture, on the whole; and indeed the rules of the business game of
profit and loss, forfeit and sequestration, require it to be so. It has
at least that much, and perhaps much else, in common with the great
technological era of the north-European neolithic age. The discipline
to which its peoples are subject may be exacting enough, and its
exactions may run to worldly wisdom rather than to matter-of-fact;
but its invidious distinctions run in terms of price, that is to say
in terms of an objective, impersonal money unit, in the last resort a
metallic weight; and the traffic of daily life under this price system
affords an unremitting exercise in the exact science of making change,
large and small. Even the daydreams of the pecuniary day-dreamer take
shape as a calculus of profit and loss computed in standard units of
an impersonal magnitude, even though the magnitude of these standard
units may on analysis prove to be of a largely putative character. The
imputation under the price system is of an impersonal kind. In the
current apprehension of the pecuniary devotee these magnitudes are
wholly objective, so that in effect the training that comes of busying
himself with them is after all a training in the accurate appreciation
of brute fact.
At the same time, the instinct of workmanship, being not an acquired
trait, has not been got rid of by disuse; and when the occasion
offers, under the relatively tranquil conditions of this peaceable or
quasi-peaceable pecuniary régime, the ancient proclivity asserts itself
in its ancient force, uneager and asthenic perhaps, but pervasive and
resilient. And when this instinct works out through the Bœotic genius
of the north-European hybrid there is a good chance that the outcome of
such observation and reflection will fall into terms of matter-of-fact,
of such close-shorn naïveté, indeed, as to afford very passable
material for the material sciences and the machine technology.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account