The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
The means whereby this work of Nature is brought to its consummate
issue are forces of Nature working under her Laws by the method
of cause and effect. The principle, or “law,” of causation is a
metaphysical postulate; in the sense that such a fact as causation is
unproved and unprovable. No man has ever observed a case of causation,
as is a commonplace with the latterday psychologists. But such a doubt
does not present itself seriously in the days of handicraft; it would
be out of touch with the spirit of the time and the discipline of
that craftsmanship out of which the spirit of the time arises. To the
inquiring minds of that era it is a matter of course and of common
sense that the forces of Nature are seen to work out the effects which
emerge before their eyes. What they see in fact may be, as the modern
psychologists would perhaps say, a certain concomitance and sequence
in the observed phenomena; but what those observers see in effect is
always a certain cause working out a certain effect. The imputation of
causal efficiency to the observed phenomena is so thoroughly a matter
of course that there is no sense of imputation in the observer’s mind.
Observation simply, without imputation of anthropomorphic qualities
and efficacies, should yield nothing more to the purpose than idle
concomitance and sequence of phenomena, but there is, in effect, none
of this early scientific work done in terms of simple concomitance
or sequence alone; nor for that matter, has any of the effective
(theoretical) work of modern science been carried to an issue by the
use of such objective terms of concomitance and sequence alone, whether
in that or in a later age, without the help of a putative causal nexus.
Through the early modern scientific period there runs an increasingly
free and frequent recourse to statistical argument,--in the material
sciences a recourse to punctilious measurement, enumeration and
instruments of precision; but it is of the essence of the case that the
phenomenal facts which so are subjected to measurement and statistical
computation are facts selected for the purpose on the strength of their
(putatively) known causal implication in the problem whose solution
is sought, and that the facts which emerge from these measurements,
computations, and instruments of precision, are turned to account in
an argument of cause and effect; they have served their purpose only
when and in so far as they enable the inquirer to determine the course
of efficient transition from a putative cause to a putative effect, or
conversely.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account