The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
history of the far-Oriental peoples, many questions of cause and effect
are found to be sufficiently disposed of when worked out in the like
terms of generation, growth and quasi-physiological mutation.
To modern inquiry explanations in these terms, other than those of
physically effective work, are provisional at the best, and are held
to only as awaiting a final solution in a materially, mechanistically
competent way. And what is alone materially competent in the modern
scientific apprehension is such an explanation as will make things
plain in terms of matter and motion, working a change in the
constitution of things by displacement through contact and pressure.
Causation is conceived as manual work,--to use a French term, it is
a _remaniement_ of raw materials at hand. Physiological or chemical
explanations must finally be recast in terms of physics, to satisfy
the modern scientist’s sense of finality, and physics must be made to
run in terms of impact, pressure, displacement in space, regrouping of
material particles, coördinated movements and a shifting of equilibrium.
Through all this runs the concomitant requirement of quantivalence,
statable in statistical form. The scientist’s results are not finally
merchantable, on the scientific exchange, until they have been reduced
to such terms of accountancy as would be comprehensible to the man
trained in the merchandising traffic of the petty trade, for whose
conviction things must be punctiliously rated in exchange value. But,
as has been noted above, it is only as an expedient of scientific
accountancy that the facts under inquiry are kept account of in an
itemised bill of values. This meticulous statistical accountancy is
necessary to safeguard the accuracy of the work done and its conformity
with the facts in hand; but the work so done handles these facts as
active factors which go efficiently to the production of the results
observed. The cause is conceived to produce the effect, somewhat after
the fashion in which a skilled workman produces a finished article
of trade. But when the scientist has set forth the operations and
working conditions that have brought forth the effects which he is
engaged in explaining, he must also, in order to the conviction of his
fellow craftsmen, show a statistically itemised statement of receipts
and expenditures covering the facts engaged,--in quantitative values
he must show that the costs are balanced by the values that emerge
in the finished product of that workmanlike process of causation
whose recondite nature and course he has so laid bare to the light of
understanding.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account