The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
As has been shown above, in its beginnings the machine technology
took over the working concepts of handicraft, and it has gradually
shifted from the ground of manual operation so afforded to the
ground of impersonal mechanical process; but this shifting of base
in respect of the elementary technological preconceptions has not
hitherto been complete, much of the personal attitude of craftsmanship
toward mechanical forces and structures being still visible in the
work of modern technologists. In like manner, and concomitant with
the transition to the machine industry, there has gone forward a
like shifting in respect of the point of view and the elementary
preconceptions of science. This has taken effect most largely and gone
farthest in the material sciences, as should be expected from the close
connection that subsists between these sciences and the technology of
the machine industry; but here again the elimination of craftsmanlike
conceptions has hitherto not been complete. And, what is more
instructive as to the part played by technological discipline in the
growth of science, the character of this change in scientific scope,
method and preconceptions is somewhat obviously such as would be given
by habituation to the working of the machine process. Where later
scientific inquiry has departed from or overpassed the limitations
imposed by the habits of thought peculiar to craftsmanship the movement
has taken the direction enforced by the machine technology.
So, _e. g._, while the elements made use of by the machine technology,
and characteristic of its work, are conceptions of mass, velocity,
pressure, stress, vibration, displacement, and the like, these
elements are made use of only under the rule that action in any of
these bearings takes effect only by impact, by contact directly or
through a continuum. The mathematical computations and elucidations
that are one main instrumentality employed by the technologist do not
and can not include this underlying postulate of contact, since it
is an assumption extraneous to those magnitudes of quantity in terms
of which this technology does its work. How far this preconception
that action can take place only by contact is to be rated as an
elementary concept carried over from handicraft, where it is obviously
at home and fundamental in all work of manipulation, may perhaps be
an idle question. In any case the machine technology is at one with
craftsmanship on this head, even though there are many features in
modern industrial processes that do not involve action by contact in
any such obvious fashion as to suggest its necessary assumption, as,
_e. g._, in processes involving the use of light, heat or electricity.
Yet it remains true that, by and large, the technology of the machine
process is a technology of action by contact; and, apparently under
stress of this wide though not necessarily universal application of the
principle, the trained technologist does not rest content until he has
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account