The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
[84] The Eskimo are placed in circumstances that are in some respects
similar to those presumed to have conditioned the life of the blond
race and its hybrids during the early phases of its life-history, and
among the traits that have made for the survival of the Eskimo is
undoubtedly to be counted the somewhat genial good-fellowship of that
race, coupled as it is with a notable disinclination to hostilities.
So also the Indians of the North-West Coast, whose situation perhaps
parallels that of the neolithic Baltic culture more closely even than
the Eskimo, are not among the notably warlike peoples of the earth,
although they undoubtedly show more of a predatory animus than their
northern neighbours. In this case it is probably safe to say that
their technological achievements have in no degree been furthered by
such warlike enterprise as they have shown, and that their comfort and
success as a race would have been even more marked if they had been
gifted with less of the warlike spirit and had kept the peace more
consistently throughout their habitat than they have done.--Cf. Franz
Boas, “The Central Eskimo,” _Bureau of American Ethnology_, Report,
1884–1885; The same, “The Secret Societies and Social Organisation of
the Kwakiutl Indians,” _Report, National Museum_, 1895; A. P. Niblack,
“Coast Indians of Southern Alaska and Northern British Columbia,”
_ibid_, 1888.
[85] Such loss by neglect of technological elements that have
been superseded may have serious consequences in case a people of
somewhat advanced attainments suffers a material set-back either in
its industrial circumstances or in its cultural situation more at
large,--as happened, e. g., in the Dark Ages of Europe. In such case
it is likely to result that the community will be unable to fall back
on a state of the industrial arts suited to the reduced circumstances
into which it finds itself thrown, having lost the use of many of the
technological elements familiar to earlier generations that lived under
similar circumstances, and so the industrial community finds itself in
many respects driven to make a virtually new beginning, from a more
rudimentary starting point than the situation might otherwise call for.
This in turn acts to throw the people back to a more archaic phase of
technology and of institutions than the initial cultural loss sustained
by the community would of itself appear to warrant.
[86] Sophus Müller, _Vor Oldtid_, “Stenalderen,” sec. iii, “Tidsforhold
i den ældre Stenalder;” O. Montelius, _Les temps préhistoriques en
Suède_, ch. i, p. 20.
[87] Compare the case of the Indians of the North-West Coast, who
have occupied a region comparable to the neolithic Baltic area in the
distribution of land and water as well as in the abundance of good
timber.
[88] Sophus Müller, _Vor Oldtid_, “Bronzealderen,” secs. xiii, xiv;
Montelius, _Les temps préhistoriques en Suède_, ch. ii.
[89] Cf., e. g., C. A. Haddon, _Evolution in Art_, section on “Magic
and Religion.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account