The intelligent woman's guide to socialism and capitalismShaw, Bernard
General
The intelligent woman's guide to socialism and capitalism
Shaw, Bernard
Capitalism; Socialism
But you are rated and taxed not only to pay for public services which
are equally useful to all, but for other things as well; and when you
come to these you may, if you are a rich woman, complain that you are
being plundered by Socialists for the benefit of the poor, or, if you
are a poor woman, that you are being plundered by Capitalists who
throw on the rents and taxes certain expenses which they should pay out
of their own pockets.
Let us see what foundation there is for such complaints. Let us begin
with the rich. By taxation rich people have a quarter or a third
of their incomes, and very rich people more than half, taken from
them by the Government, not for any specified public service, but as
pure nationalization (communization) of their income to that extent
without any compensation, and by simple coercion. This is now taken so
completely as a matter of course that the rich never dream of asking
for compensation, or refusing to pay until their goods are forcibly
seized, or even of calling it Bolshevik confiscation; and so we are apt
to talk as if such things never happened except in the imaginations
of wicked Communists; but they happen in Great Britain regularly
every January; and the Act authorizing them is brought in every April
by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. Though reassuringly called the
Appropriation Act it is really an Expropriation Act.
There is nothing in the law or the Constitution, or in any custom or
tradition or parliamentary usage or any other part of our established
morality, to prevent this confiscated third or half being raised to
three-quarters, nine-tenths, or the whole. Besides this, when a very
rich person dies, the Government confiscates the entire income of the
property for the next eight years. The smallest taxable properties have
to give up their incomes to the Government for ten months, and the rest
for different periods between these extremes, in proportion to their
amount.
In addition, there are certain taxes paid by rich and poor alike,
called indirect taxes. Some of them are taxes on certain articles of
food, and on tobacco and spirits, which you pay in the shop when you
buy them, as part of the price. Others are stamp duties: twopence
if you give a receipt for £2 or more, sixpence if you make a simple
written agreement, hundreds of pounds on certain other documents which
propertyless people never use. None of these taxes are levied for a
named service like the police rate or the water rate: they are simple
transfers of income from private pockets to the national pocket, and,
as such, acts of pure Communism. It may surprise you to learn that even
without counting the taxes on food, which fall on all classes, the
private property thus communized already amounts to nearly a million a
day.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account