The International Monthly, Volume 5, No. 4, April, 1852Various
History
The International Monthly, Volume 5, No. 4, April, 1852
Various
Art, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals; Science -- History -- Periodicals
When a saying has passed into a national proverb, it is regarded as
having received the "hall-mark" of the people, with respect to its
prudence or practical wisdom. Proverbs deal only with realities,
generally of the most homely and every-day kind, and are always supposed
to comprise the most sage advice, or the most broad worldly truth,
within the least possible compass.
Now, while we admit that proverbs are for the most part true, and useful
in their teaching, and that they very often inculcate excellent maxims,
we must at the same time enter our protest against the infallibility of
most of them. Numbers will be found, on the least examination (which is
seldom given to them) to be one-sided truths; others, inculcate an
utterly selfish conduct, under the guise of prudence or worldly wisdom;
and some of them are absolutely false, or only of the narrowest
application. The majority of the proverbs, of all modern nations,
originate with the people, and with the humbler classes (we must except
the Chinese and Arabic, which are evidently the product of their sages),
as witnessed by the homeliness of the allusions, and the frequent
vulgarity, but, in all cases, the actual experience of life and its
ordinary occurences with regard to men and things. They are full of
corn, with a proportionate quantity of chaff and straw. Let us no
longer, therefore, take all these "sayings" for granted; let us rather
take them to task a little, for their revision and our own good.
Proverbs being the common property of all mankind, and often to be
traced to very remote geographical sources, we shall observe no national
classification; but string a few together now and then from Arabia and
China, from Spain, Italy, France, or England, just as they may occur.
So, now to our first string.
_Honesty is the best policy._ This is true in the higher sense; but
doubtful in the sense usually intended. It is true as to the general
good, but not usually for the individual, except in the long run. (We
pass over the obvious truth, that it is better policy to earn a guinea,
than to steal one, because the proverb has a far wider range of meaning
than that.) To be a "politic," clever fellow, a vast deal more humoring
of prejudices, errors, and follies, is requisite, than at all assorts
with true honesty of character. If, however, we regard this proverb only
on its higher moral ground, then, of course, we must at once admit its
truth. The reader will probably be surprised, as we were, to find that
it comes from the Chinese, and will be found in the translation of the
novel of "_Iu-Kiao-Li_."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account