The Irish Penny Journal, Vol. 1 No. 38, March 20, 1841Various
History
The Irish Penny Journal, Vol. 1 No. 38, March 20, 1841
Various
Ireland -- Periodicals
In as far, then, as the phenomenon of boulders is exhibited in the low
lands of Europe (leaving other countries out of the question), it seems
quite in conformity with the operations of causes such as have been
here explained. But it may next be asked, How does the ice-transporting
theory explain the boulders of the Alps? Had the waters been sufficiently
elevated to convey icebergs over the Jura chain, the Scandinavian
mountains would have been deeply submerged, and no longer, therefore, a
source either of ice or of boulders. This is unquestionably a difficulty,
unless it be assumed either that some great change of relative altitude
has taken place by the uplifting of the Alps since the deposition of
its boulders, or that the Alpine boulders have not been conveyed by
marine agencies. Lyell supposed it possible that falling “hill-sides”
might have dammed up the rallies of Switzerland, and have formed lakes,
on which the icebergs from its uplifted glaciers might have floated
across to the Jura, and have been carried down to the low country at
the base of the Alps, by the sudden bursting of the barrier, and the
flood following it; and Wissmann (who strangely enough ranks Lyell,
manifestly his precursor in this idea, amongst the advocates of the
theory of torrents) in like manner assumes the existence of a large sea
extending over the low portion of Switzerland, the country now bordering
on the Lake of Constance, and the greater part of Bavaria, on the
waters of which the ice of falling glaciers with its cargo of boulders
floated across. This sea was not however, like Lyell’s, the result of a
secondary accident, but arose, encircled and walled in by mountains, on
the last upheaving of the Alps. Its waters overflowing their boundary
at the lowest points, according to Wissmann enlarged the passages of
discharge, which giving vent to the waters, gradually lowered and finally
emptied the sea, leaving the valley of the Rhone and of the Rhine as a
relic. If, however, hypotheses of at least equal probability have been
rejected either as depending too much on supposititious data, or as
being imperfect explanations of the phenomena, there seems no greater
reason for admitting these. Such accidents as those suggested by Mr Lyell
have indeed occurred in the Alpine regions; rivers have been dammed up
either by falling hill-sides or by falling masses of ice, and on bursting
through these obstacles, have poured down in fearful destruction on the
plain below. But how diminutive are such catastrophes in comparison to
that which must have attended on the dispersion of the Alpine boulders!
and although the lake of Wissmann’s hypothesis is sufficiently extensive
to transport the boulders through a very wide space, it is insufficient
to account for those in Franche-compté; whilst, if we suppose with him
that the last elevation of the Alps was prior to the deposition of the
Molasse, it seems improbable that all the great openings of discharge,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account