The Irrational Knot: Being the Second Novel of His Nonage — John Shaqi
The Irrational Knot: Being the Second Novel of His NonageShaw, Bernard
General
The Irrational Knot: Being the Second Novel of His Nonage
Shaw, Bernard
Marriage -- Fiction; Social classes -- Fiction
I had, to begin with, a sort of backstairs knowledge; for in my teens I
struggled for life in the office of an Irish gentleman who acted as
land agent and private banker for many persons of distinction. Now it
is possible for a London author to dine out in the highest circles for
twenty years without learning as much about the human frailties of his
hosts as the family solicitor or (in Ireland) the family land agent
learns in twenty days; and some of this knowledge inevitably reaches
his clerks, especially the clerk who keeps the cash, which was my
particular department. He learns, if capable of the lesson, that the
aristocratic profession has as few geniuses as any other profession; so
that if you want a peerage of more than, say, half a dozen members, you
must fill it up with many common persons, and even with some deplorably
mean ones. For “service is no inheritance” either in the kitchen or the
House of Lords; and the case presented by Mr. Barrie in his play of The
Admirable Crichton, where the butler is the man of quality, and his
master, the Earl, the man of rank, is no fantasy, but a quite common
occurrence, and indeed to some extent an inevitable one, because the
English are extremely particular in selecting their butlers, whilst
they do not select their barons at all, taking them as the accident of
birth sends them. The consequences include much ironic comedy. For
instance, we have in England a curious belief in first rate people,
meaning all the people we do not know; and this consoles us for the
undeniable secondrateness of the people we do know, besides saving the
credit of aristocracy as an institution. The unmet aristocrat is
devoutly believed in; but he is always round the corner, never at hand.
That _the_ smart set exists; that there is above and beyond that smart
set a class so blue of blood and exquisite in nature that it looks down
even on the King with haughty condescension; that scepticism on these
points is one of the stigmata of plebeian baseness: all these
imaginings are so common here that they constitute the real popular
sociology of England as much as an unlimited credulity as to
vaccination constitutes the real popular science of England. It is, of
course, a timid superstition. A British peer or peeress who happens by
chance to be genuinely noble is just as isolated at court as Goethe
would have been among all the other grandsons of publicans, if they had
formed a distinct class in Frankfurt or Weimar. This I knew very well
when I wrote my novels; and if, as I suspect, I failed to create a
convincingly verisimilar atmosphere of aristocracy, it was not because
I had any illusions or ignorances as to the common humanity of the
peerage, and not because I gave literary style to its conversation, but
because, as I had never had any money, I was foolishly indifferent to
it, and so, having blinded myself to its enormous importance,
necessarily missed the point of view, and with it the whole moral
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account