The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
Of two positions, then, we must choose one. Either the miracle-stories
of the gospels, and by consequence those of the Acts, were as such
otiose inventions for an audience which, on the view under discussion,
would have been much more responsive to an explicit claim of triumph
over polytheistic beliefs, the thing they are said to have been most
deeply concerned about, or the miracle stories in general were meant
as miracle-stories, only some later symbolists seeking to impose a
symbolic sense on the records along with the Gnostic conception that
the Christ had spoken in allegories which the people were not meant to
understand. This later manipulation undoubtedly did take place. The
parable of the Rich One, as Professor Smith convincingly shows, is
an allegory of Jew and Gentile--the Rich One being Israel. But it is
not by such manipulation that cults are made popular, congregations
collected, and revenue secured. And it was on these practical lines
that Christianity was "stablished."
The factors which made this one Eastern cult gradually gain ground,
and finally hold its ground, as against the many rival cults, were--
1. The system of ecclesiæ, modelled at once on the Jewish synagogue
and the pagan collegia.
2. The practice of mutual help, making the churches Friendly
Societies--again an assimilation of common pagan practice.
3. The colligation of the churches, primarily by means of a new sacred
literature of gospels and epistles, and secondarily by a system of
centralized government, partly modelled on the imperial system.
4. The backing of the new Christian Sacred Books by the Jewish Sacred
Books, giving an ancient Eastern background and basis for the faith
in a world in which Eastern religious elements were progressively
overriding the Western, which had in comparison no documentary basis.
5. The giving to the whole process a relatively democratic character,
again after the model of the Jewish system, wherein the people had
their main recognition as human beings with rights. Thus Christianity
was at once a "secret society" under an autocracy, as were so many
Hellenistic religious groups, drawing members as such societies always
do in autocratically governed States, [339] and a popular movement as
contrasted with Mithraism, which always remained a mere secret society,
whence its easy ultimate suppression by the Christianized government.
6. It was the wide ramification and popular importance of the Christian
system that at length made it worth the while of the emperor to cease
persecuting it as a partly anti-imperial organization and to turn it
into an imperial instrument by making it the religion of the State.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account