The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
To explain the process as the morally deserved success of a religion
superior from the start, in virtue of the superiority of its nominal
Founder, would be to adhere to pre-scientific conceptions of causation,
akin to the geocentric assumption in astronomy. Hierology ultimately
merges in sociology, as mythology and anthropology (in the English
limitation of the term) merge in hierology; and sociology is a study of
the reaction of environments as well as of the action of institutions
and doctrines. The Christian success was finally achieved by the
assimilation of all manner of pagan modes of attraction on the side
of creed, and the absolute ultimate subordination of the specialties
of early Christian ethic to the business of political adaptation.
And to all attempts to obscure the problem by figuring Christianity as
a continuously beneficent and purifying force it is sufficient here to
answer that it is in strict fact a religious variant which survived in
a decaying civilization, a politically and socially decaying world;
that it lent itself to that decay; and that it did less than nothing
to avert it.
Where superior hostile power efficiently fought it, it was suppressed
just as it suppressed the organized cults of paganism and some
(not all) of its own heretical sects. Its further survival, which
does not here properly concern us, was but a matter of the renewed
"triumph" of an organized over unorganized religions, and of the
adoption of that organization by the new barbaric States as before
by the declining Roman empire.
CHAPTER V
ORGANIZATION AND ECONOMICS
§ 1. The Economic Side
It is important to realize in some detail the operation of the economic
factor in particular, and of organization in general, before we try
to grasp synthetically the total process of documentary and doctrinal
construction. The former is somewhat sedulously ignored in ordinary
historiography, by reason of a general unwillingness even among
rationalists to seem to connect mercenary motives with religious
beginnings; and of the general assumption among religionists that
"true" or "early" religion operates in spite of, in defiance or
in independence of and not by aid of, economic motives. No one
will dispute that the history of the Roman Catholic Church is one
of economic as well as doctrinal action and reaction, or that
Protestantism from the first was in large measure an economic
processus. But it is commonly assumed, at least implicitly, that
"primitive" religion, religion "in the making," is not at all an
affair of economic motive or reaction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account