The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
To discuss in similar detail the myths of the Apocryphal gospels
and the still later myths of Catholic Christendom would only be to
extend the area of our demonstration without adding to its scientific
weight. The general result would only be to prove derivations from
pagan sources and to exhibit more fully the process (a) of inventing
sayings of Jesus to vindicate different views of his Messianic
and other functions, and (b) of enforcing ethical views by his
authority. The legend of St. Christopher, for instance, is but a
variant, probably iconographic in motive, of a multiform pagan myth
which probably roots in a ritual of child-carrying. [428] Iconography
yields many evidences. The conventional figure of the Good-Shepherd
carrying a sheep, which like the Birth-Story has counted for so much
in popularizing Christianity, is admittedly derived from pagan art,
[429] like the conventional angel-figure. Even the figure of Peter
[430] as the bearer of the keys, head of the Twelve, and denier of his
Lord, connects curiously with the myths of Proteus and Janus Bifrons,
[431] both bearers of the cosmic keys.
Iconography, again, is probably the source, for the gospels, of the
myth of the Temptation, which professional scholars continue solemnly
to discuss as a "biographical" episode to be somehow reduced to
historicity. The story coincides so absolutely with the Græco-Roman
account, evidently derived from painting or sculpture, of Pan (in
figure the Satan of the Jews) standing by the young Jupiter on a
mountain-top before an altar, [432] that it might seem unnecessary
to go further. But, recognizing that "of myth there is no 'original,'
save man's immemorial dream," and remembering that there are similar
Temptation myths concerning Buddha and Zarathustra, we are bound to
extend the inquiry. The results are very interesting.
We are specially concerned with the versions of Matthew and Luke,
of which Dr. Spitta, by analysis, finds the Lucan the earlier,
[433] pronouncing the Marcan to be a curtailment and manipulation,
not the primary source, as was maintained by Von Harnack and many
others. [434] The essence of the story, as episode, is the presence
of the God and the Adversary on a high place, surveying "the kingdoms
of the world." This originates proximately in Babylonian astronomy
and astrology, where the Goat-God is represented standing beside
the Sun-God on "the mountain of the world," that is, the height of
the heavens, at the beginning of the sun's yearly course in the
sign Capricorn, which, personified, figures as the sun's tutor
and guide. Graphically represented, it is the origin of a series
of Greek myths--Pan and Zeus; Marsyas and Apollo; Silenus and
Dionysos--all turning on a goat-legged figure beside a young God on
a mountain-top. Satan and Jesus are but another variant, probably
deriving from Greek iconography, but possibly more directly from the
East, where the idea of a Temptation goes back to the Vedas.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account