The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
The theologians, reluctantly admitting, of late, that the Devil could
not carry Jesus through the air, anxiously debate as to whether or
not Jesus had strange psychic experiences which he communicated to
his disciples; and, utterly ignoring comparative mythology, look for
motivation, as usual, only in the Old Testament. Spitta, after checking
these researches, and declaring that the man is not to be envied who
hopes to explain the story by Old Testament parallels from the forty
years of wandering in the wilderness, [435] confidently concludes
that it stands for the spiritual experience of Jesus in regard to
his Messianic ideal. [436] To such a biographical inference he has
not the slightest critical right on his own principles. The gospels
say nothing whatever of any communication on the subject by Jesus
to his disciples. The story is myth pure and simple, and belongs to
universal mythology.
Mark turned the story to the illustration of the doctrine laid down
in the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, [437] that devils and wild
beasts will flee from the righteous man; and Luke and Matthew turn it
into an affirmation of the theological maxims of Jewish monotheism; but
these are simply the invariable practices of the evangelists, steeped
in the habits of thought of Jewish symbolism. The myth remains; and the
story, as story, has counted for a great deal more in Christian popular
lore than the theology. When the writer of the fourth gospel put the
miracle of turning water into wine in the forefront of his work, he
doubtless had symbolic intentions; [438] but his story is simply an
adaptation of the annual Dionysiac rite of turning water into wine at
the festival of the God on Twelfth Night. [439] It may have come either
from the Greek or from the eastern side. The duplicated tale of the
Feeding of the Five Thousand, again, is either an adaptation of or an
attempt to excel the story of the feeding of the host of Dionysos in
a waterless desert in his campaign against the Titans. [440] As the
God had the power of miraculously producing, by touch, corn and wine
and oil, his lore doubtless included miracles of feeding. The touch
of the seating of the people "in ranks, by hundreds, and by fifties"
(Mk. vi, 40) suggests a pictorial source.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account