The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
But the thing alleged is unnatural. On the one hand we are asked to
believe that the authorities had before sunset collected a number of
witnesses, when they could not have any certainty of making the arrest;
on the other hand we are to believe that with all this extraordinary
fore-planning they had not taken the normal precaution of ascertaining
what the witnesses could say. In the transcribed drama as it stands,
the authorities are represented as knaves; in the interpretation
before us, framed to save the credit of the narrative, they are
represented as childishly foolish. The narrative as we have it defies
its vindicators. It tells that witnesses were sent for; and only in
a drama, in which time-conditions are ignored, could such a fiction
have been resorted to.] #/
The story is equally dramatic to the close. Everything is scenic,
detached, episodic: it is left to Luke (who elaborates the
Supper scene; gives a positive command of Jesus for the future
celebration where the previous documents merely show the rite as it
was practised; puts the denial of Peter before the trial; and drops
the whole procedure of the witnesses) to interpose the episode of the
daughters of Jerusalem between the Roman trial and the crucifixion;
and even that is parenthetic and dramatic, as are the burial and
the seeking; whereafter, in Mark, the gospel abruptly ends. The
rest is supplementary documentation. How much of that may have been
dramatized, it is impossible to say. That there had been evolution
in the mystery-play is involved in our conception of it. It began
with the simple Sacrament, at a remote period, the Sacrament itself
being evolved from a primitive and savage to a symbolic form, the God
being probably first represented, as in kindred rites, [221] by his
sacrificial priest; and later by the victim. [222] It is after the
primitive and localized cult seeks the status of a world-religion that
the ritual developes into a quasi-history; and we can see conflicting
influences in that. One writer causes Jesus to be buffeted and mocked
at the Jewish trial, as if to counterbalance the derision in the Roman
trial; even as Luke interposes a third trial before Herod, to make sure
that the guilt should ultimately lie with the Jewish government. In the
action as in the doctrine, the Gentile influence finally predominates.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account