The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
This said, we have still to face the main problem of the evolution of
the Jesus-cult into a world-religion in which the God Sacrificed to
the God becomes also the Messiah of the Jews and the Teacher of those
who believe in him. And the tracing of that evolution must obviously
be difficult. The process of extracting true out of false history
is always so; and where the concocted history and its contingent
literature are the main documents, we can in the nature of things
reach only general conceptions. But general conceptions are attainable;
and we must frame them as scientifically as we can.
CHAPTER IV
THE EVOLUTION OF THE CULT
§ 1. The Primary Impulsion
Professor W. B. Smith, whose brilliant, independent, and powerful
advocacy of the myth-theory has brought conviction to readers not
otherwise attracted by it, has stressed two propositions in regard
to the evolution of the Jesus-cult. One is that the movement was
"multifocal," starting from a number of points; [225] the other that
the essential and inspiring motive was the monotheistic conception,
as against all forms of polytheism; Jesus being conceived as "the One
God." [226] That the first proposition is sound and highly important,
I am convinced. But after weighing the second with a full sense of the
acumen that guides all Professor Smith's constructive speculation, I
remain of the opinion that it needs considerable modification. [227]
In clearing up these two issues, we shall go a long way towards
establishing a clear theory of the whole historical process.
In the first place, a "multifocal" movement, a growth from many points,
is involved in all our knowledge of the highly important matters of the
history of the early Christian sects, and the non-canonical Christian
documents. Perhaps the proposition is even more widely true than
Professor Smith indicates. To begin with, we find at an early stage
the sects of (1) Ebionites and (2) Nazarenes or Nazareans, in addition
to (3 and 4) the Judaizing and Gentilizing movements associated with
"the Twelve" and Paul respectively; and yet further (5) the movement
associated with the name of Apollos. Further we have to note (6) the
Jesuism of the Apocalypse, partly extra-Judaic in its derivation;
and (7) that of the ninth section of the Teaching of the Twelve
Apostles, which emerges as a quasi-Ebionitic addition to a purely
Judaic document--not yet interpolated by the seventh section. Yet
further, we have (8) the factors accruing to the religious epithet
"Chrestos" [228] (= good, gracious), which specially attached to the
underworld Gods of the Samothracian mysteries; also to Hermes, Osiris,
and Isis; and (9 and 10) the Christist cult-movements connected with
the non-Jesuine Pastor of Hermas and the sect of the Eleesaites. [229]
And this is not an exhaustive list.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account