In the seventeenth chapter of the Second Book of “The Guide” Maimonides
says as follows: “Everything produced comes into existence from
non-existence; even when the substance of a thing has been in
existence, and has only changed its form, the thing itself which has
gone through the process of genesis and development, after having
arrived at its final state, has properties different from those which
it possessed at the commencement of the transition from potentiality to
reality or before that time.... It is quite impossible to infer from
the qualities which a thing possesses after having passed through all
the stages of its development what its condition was at the moment when
this process commenced; nor does the condition of a thing at that
moment show what its previous condition had been. If you make this
mistake, and attempt to prove the nature of a thing in potential
existence by its properties when actually existing, you will fall into
great confusion; you will reject evident truth and admit false
opinions.... If philosophers would consider this well, and reflect on
it, they would find that it represents exactly the dispute between
Aristotle and ourselves. We, the followers of Moses, our teacher, and
of Abraham, our father, believe that the universe has been produced
from nothing, and has developed in a certain manner, and that it has
been created in a certain order. The Aristotelians oppose us, and found
their objections on the properties which the things in the universe
possess when in actual existence and fully developed. We admit the
existence of these properties, but hold that these properties
themselves have come into existence from absolute non-existence. The
arguments of our opponents are thus refuted; they have demonstrative
force only against those who hold that the nature of things as at
present in existence proves the Creation. But this is not my opinion.”
This reasoning holds good with regard to the modern theory of
Evolution. We may be able to discover numerous facts in evidence of
this theory, we may well conceive the idea of a protoplasm developing
into a whole system of worlds, and yet our belief in the truth of the
Biblical account of the Creation is not shaken in the least. The laws
of Evolution are the result of the creative act of the Almighty, and
not its causes; they include nothing that could disprove the
correctness of the theory of Creatio ex nihilo.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account