It is well-known that a primary Greek distinction was that between
Hellene and barbarian, and it is equally familiar that the distinction
had not been fully formed in the time of Homer. There is no indication
that the Trojans were felt to be fundamentally different from the
Acheans, although it is likely enough that the allies who attacked the
great city of the Troad were of different descent from those that
defended it. The one instance found in Homer of the word
βάρβαρος is in the compound βαρβαρόφωνος, “of
barbarous speech” (Iliad ii. 867), which makes the original meaning of
the word apparent. A Greek was one whose speech was intelligible. All
others were barbarians, “jabberers.” And it is not only incidentally
that Homer fails to make the racial division clear. When he of set
purpose contrasts the two armies, as in Iliad iv. 422-437, it is the
contrast between the silent discipline of the Greeks and the loose,
noisy marshaling of the Trojans: “For all were not of one speech or of a
single language. Mixed were their tongues, since the men came from
far-off lands.”
It is probably in the course of just such expeditions as the Iliad tells
of, a joint movement against a common foe, that a sense of national
unity arose, and it is likely that it came to include many tribes of
different race. We do not know what real basis there is for the
traditional divisions of Ionians, Dorians, and Aeolians. These divisions
have not proved very valuable means of classification to modern students
of Greek dialects. The generic name of Greek to the East was Yavan,
obviously the same as Ionian,[46] and that name indicates where the
first contact took place. The struggles of Greeks to establish
themselves on the coast of Asia Minor probably created the three
traditional groups, by forcing them to combine against threatened
destruction. But there is nothing to show that any real feeling of
common origin and common responsibility existed even here.
On the continent, again, there were large groups of men whom the Greeks
found difficulty in classifying. There were some Epirotes and
Macedonians whose claim to be Greeks was admitted. On the whole,
however, Epirotes and Macedonians were classed as barbarians, though a
different sort of barbarians from Scythian and Phrygian. The first
realization of national unity came with the first great national danger,
the catastrophe that impended from the Persians.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account