The Journal of Geology, January-February 1893: A Semi-Quarterly Magazine of Geology and Related SciencesVarious
Science
The Journal of Geology, January-February 1893: A Semi-Quarterly Magazine of Geology and Related Sciences
Various
Geology -- Periodicals
The difficulty of taking up and re-examining evidence, of which the
record only remains, is, however, very great, since in most cases
the evidence rests upon or consists of field observations, and these
cannot be recalled or repeated, and there is absolutely no means of
testing directly the value of what is recorded. One may seek either to
verify or to discredit the promulgated theories, but years of search
may fail to produce a single new item of evidence bearing decisively
upon the subject. It is possible that at one period numerous finds of
implements should be reported from certain portions of the gravels,
and that afterwards the whole remaining body of these formations
should be worked over and searched without securing a trace of art;
yet this latter evidence, being negative, need not necessarily be
considered sufficient to overturn the original positive evidence if
that happens to be of a high class. There is not the least doubt,
however, that positive evidence may be so impaired by various defects
and inconsistencies, that, unsupported by renewed and well verified
observations, it will finally yield to the negative forces; and if
the theories of a gravel man in the eastern United States, howsoever
fortified by accumulated observations, are not really properly
supported in every way, they are bound in time to fall to the ground.
All I can reasonably hope to do now is to have the evidence relating to
glacial man placed on trial, and so fully examined and cross-examined
that those who accept gravel man need not longer do so blindly without
knowing that there are two sides to the question, and those who do not
accept him may know something of the reasons for the belief that is in
them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account