The Journal of Geology, January-February 1893: A Semi-Quarterly Magazine of Geology and Related SciencesVarious
Science
The Journal of Geology, January-February 1893: A Semi-Quarterly Magazine of Geology and Related Sciences
Various
Geology -- Periodicals
The "Eskimo" feature of the scheme requires a more detailed examination
than can be given it here. It may be stated, however, that the
separation of the so-called Eskimo spear points, or whatever they
may be, from the great body of associated articles of flaked stone,
appears to be a highly arbitrary proceeding. That they were extensively
made by the Indians is proved by the occurrence of refuse resulting
from their manufacture on modern shop sites, and that they were used
by the Indian, is equally apparent from their common occurrence on
modern dwelling sites. The exceptionally large size of the argellite
points is readily accounted for by the nature of the material. It was
the only stone of the region well adapted to the manufacture of long
blades or projectile points. Jasper, quartz and flint have such minute
cleavage that, save in rare cases, small implements only could be
made from them. Their peculiar manner of occurrence, described at so
much length by Dr. Abbott,[6] has been given undue consideration and
weight. The phenomena observed may all be accounted for as a result of
the vicissitudes of aboriginal life and occupation within the last few
hundred years as fully and satisfactorily as by jumping thousands of
years backward into the unknown.
[6] Abbott, C. C. Popular Science Monthly, Dec., 1889.
Whatsoever real support there may be for the "Eskimo" theory, either in
the published or the unpublished evidence, it is apparent that under
the present system of solitary and inexpert research, the scientific
world will gain little that it can utilize without distrust and danger.
Whatsoever may be the final outcome--which outcome is bound to be the
truth--it is clear that there is little in the present evidence to
warrant the separation of a "paleolithic" and an "Eskimo" period of art
from that of the Indian.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account