The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy 1919 (New Series, No. 58)Pennsylvania Prison Society
History
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy 1919 (New Series, No. 58)
Pennsylvania Prison Society
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
In Pennsylvania, as in most, if not all, of the other States of the
Union, the county jail is the despair of those who look for a better
day in the treatment of the wrong-doer. The admiration which our
experiments in the reformatory treatment of the young have excited
in eminent foreign penologists has turned to loathing when their
attention was directed to the county jails. Sir Evelyn Ruggles-Brise,
the distinguished head of the English prison system, in an article
published a few months after his visit to this country in 1910,
described them in the following terms:
“In these gaols it is hardly too much to say that many of the
features linger which called forth the wrath and indignation
of the great Howard at the end of the eighteenth century.
Promiscuity, unsanitary conditions, absence of supervision,
idleness and corruption--these remain the features in many
places. Even the ‘fee’ system is still in vogue. The gaolers are
still paid by fees for the support of prisoners, and commitments
to gaol are common when some other disposition of the case would
have been imposed had not the commitment yielded a fee to the
sheriff, who is usually in charge of the gaol. In many gaols
there are not facilities for medical examination on reception,
for ventilation, for exercise, or for bathing.... The foreign
delegates were amazed at this startling inconsistency between the
management of the common gaols and that of the State prisons and
State reformatories. The evils to which I refer are well known
and deplored by that body of earnest and devoted men and women in
all sections of American society with whose lofty ideals on the
subject of prison reform and generous aspirations for the humane
treatment of the prisoner, the Washington Congress made us every
day familiar, but they seem helpless and almost hopeless....
I was appealed to by leading men in more than one State, as
British representative, to publicly condemn the system, and this
I did, at a risk of giving considerable offense. Until the abuses
of the gaol system are removed, it is impossible for America to
have assigned to her by general consent a place in the vanguard
of progress in the domain of ‘_la science penitentiaire_.’”
Your Commission desires to submit as its considered judgment that the
foregoing statement does no injustice to many of the county prisons of
this Commonwealth, and that the Legislature can do no greater service,
nor one that will reflect more credit on the Commonwealth, than to
sweep away the entire county jail system without delay.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account