The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 3, January 1864)Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons
History
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 3, January 1864)
Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
The distinguishing feature of the discipline which this Society has
advocated for Penitentiaries, is that which the world misrepresents by
denominating it _solitary_ confinement, and which it discredits by
arguments founded not on past experience, but resting upon the probable
effects upon the minds of the prisoners of total solitude and utter
separation from association, sight and converse with man. We do not
pretend to say what would be the effect of such a condition. Our object
is not the condemnation of an untried system, but the exposition of the
benefits of that which has been well tested. The amelioration not the
augmentation of prison discipline is the object of our Association. The
permanent benefit of society through the improvement of individuals, or
the eternal benefit of individuals, by making the prison a school of
reform rather than a place of torture. Separate confinement is the
object that has been proposed—and wherever obtained, it has produced, if
not all the good which had been hoped for, at least more than any other
system that has been adopted, and has satisfied those who are engaged
officially or voluntarily in its administration, that its benefits are
progressive. By the separation of the convict from his fellow criminals,
he is taken from the concerted plans and practices of crime, and placed
where none may approach him but officers charged with the care of his
person, or those who visit his cell with messages of kindness. People
who, sensible of his guilt, but hopeful of his reformation, approach him
in a spirit of kindness, and, satisfying him that they seek his good,
and not their own benefit, gain admittance to his heart, win his
confidence, and produce, perhaps, solemn resolutions to amend. He sees,
in the narrow confines of his cell, and he feels, in the strictness of
the discipline to which he is subjected, the terrors of the violated
law. But he comprehends, in the oft-repeated lessons of love that are
given to him by the Society’s visitors, that, prone as he is to crime,
he is the object of human solicitude and the subject of divine mercy.
And in time he understands also, that, had he been released with the
first resolution to repent, he would have missed of reform. He
comprehends that time and retirement were necessary to the germination
of the seeds which had been planted in his heart, and a long season of
abstraction from society could alone have matured the fruits of
repentance. Solitude—entire solitude—might have embittered his heart
against the social compact by which he was suffering. He may have had
learning, but he probably lacked that moral education, that culture of
the heart, by which he could easily discern the rightful dependence of
punishment on crime, or his responsibility to society for the talents he
possessed, and the uses to which he applied them. In utter loneliness,
he would have brooded over his privations, and, recalling the hundreds
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account