The journal of prison discipline and philanthropy (New series, No. 57), March, 1918Pennsylvania Prison Society
History
The journal of prison discipline and philanthropy (New series, No. 57), March, 1918
Pennsylvania Prison Society
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
The meetings of the American Prison Association in 1917 were held
in New Orleans, November 19-23. Outside of the State of Louisiana,
the registration of delegates and attenders amounted to 261, of whom
seven were from Canada, one from Mexico, one from Cuba and one from
Guatemala. One hundred and thirty-seven registered from Louisiana.
Outside of this State, Massachusetts enrolled the largest number,
thirty-two being accredited to the Bay State. Then followed New York,
with twenty-nine, and Pennsylvania was third with twenty-two, of whom
nine were Official Delegates. It must not be forgotten that there were
many attenders at these meetings who had not received appointment as
Official Delegates, but who were active and welcome participators in
the discussions. In 1916 and 1917, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania has
been well represented, but for several years previous the attendance
from the Keystone State had, from a numerical point of view, been
rather insignificant.
THE PRESIDENT’S ADDRESS.
Dr. David C. Peyton, Superintendent of the Indiana Reformatory at
Jeffersonville, ably officiated as presiding officer of the various
sessions of the Association. He is evidently a believer in strict
discipline administered by the officials who are legally appointed as
the guardians of the offender, yet no one who visits the institution
over which he presides, would assert that the regulations are harsh or
unreasonable. His view of the Honor System would not involve government
by the inmates.
“In prison management there have developed two colossal evils. One
was peculiar to the past and the other in a measure characterizes
the present. Most of the evils that are associated with prison work
have come from these two roots. They are antipodal as east and west.
They are cruelty and sentimentality. As the first was the child of
ignorance, the second springs from half knowledge and is not the less
reprehensible. True reform will come, not by a softening and relaxation
in prison discipline, not by imputing to criminals qualities which
their whole activities have proven them to lack and the very absence of
which is the cause of their incarceration, not by making their pathway
smoother and easier, nor yet by touching it with the magic of romance.
If a little of the leaven of common sense were allowed to permeate the
situation it seems to me that the clouds in our pathway would lift
somewhat.
“Of course cruelty, the other bête-noir, is only named to be condemned,
and thanks to our even half-knowledge it has no place in modern prisons
except in isolated spots. But I doubt if ever cruelty was any more
cruel than a regime which threatens to become popular today. It seems
to me that prisons should be run for the purpose of training men for
sane living. If that is true, then they should in fact train these men
for sane living.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account