The journal of prison discipline and philanthropy (New series, No. 57), March, 1918Pennsylvania Prison Society
History
The journal of prison discipline and philanthropy (New series, No. 57), March, 1918
Pennsylvania Prison Society
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
Mr. Derrick informed the Association that this California school has
developed its honor system to the point where 250 of the boys were
sent to the Sacramento fair alone, traveling through the country 250
miles, and returning without the loss of a single one. The boys have a
complete republic system of government, and conduct all of the work of
the school. A football team plays regular school and college teams of
the State, traveling without supervision.
It appeared to some of us who listened with intense interest to these
discussions that the difference in sentiment was rather one of degree
than of principle. Wherever any privileges are allowed and wherever
the trusty system is permitted, there is involved some measure of
self-government. One warden permits the prisoners to mingle together
on the base ball field. These men are on their honor. Another warden
might say that he would allow his prisoners to play and observe games
and leave the regulation of their conduct while on the field to the
men themselves. They are still on their honor and doubtless are aware
that their regulation of conduct must meet the approval of the warden.
Suppose we allow the men to impose penalties for minor delinquencies.
The warden still exercises his judgment on the punishment awarded. The
warden governs. The men may have more or less privileges, but they are
granted by the warden. It resolves itself into a question as to how far
such privileges may be granted. And no two wardens in the world will
agree precisely on this point.
For the last twenty years the trend has been getting away from the
brutality of the former systems, from the petty rules, from degrading
and humiliating treatment, and the avowed object of confinement has
been reiterated again and again to aim at reformation. We admit that
some wardens are more successful than others in accomplishing desired
results, and yet we must not expect them to adopt an entirely uniform
program. We must make due allowance for the personal equation involved,
for the individuality of the ruling authority. The warden who claims
that his system is perfect, and that he has nothing more to learn, is
recommended for removal.
CLINICAL WORK.
Dr. Bernard Glueck exhibited a number of charts showing much that
was deeply interesting in regard to the mentality, environment and
parentage of the criminals sent to Sing Sing.
“Sing Sing is being reorganized and rebuilt to receive all of the
criminals of New York for examination immediately after they have been
convicted. We are trying to get at the man behind the crime rather
than the crime itself. Two facts are very evident from our work. The
social fact is that 66 per cent. of the prisoners we have received
are previous offenders. The medical fact is that 59 per cent. of the
prisoners can be classified for mental diseases or mental deviation;
and thousands of this class can be treated and cured by means of
vocational training and other modern prison methods.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account