The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867Various
Philosophy
The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
So far as this goes, the teacher of Idealism shows his assertion to be
contained in immediate consciousness. But that this necessary manner is
the fundamental law of all reason, that from it the whole system of our
necessary representations, not only of a world and the determinedness
and relations of objects, but also of ourselves, as free and practical
beings acting under laws, can be deduced. All this is a mere
presupposition, which can only be proven by the actual deduction, which
deduction is therefore the real business of the teacher.
In realizing this deduction, he proceeds as follows: _He shows that the
first fundamental law which was discovered in immediate consciousness,
is not possible, unless a second action is combined with it, which again
is not possible without a third action; and so on, until the conditions
of the First are completely exhausted, and itself is now made perfectly
comprehensible in its possibility_. The teacher’s method is a continual
progression from the conditioned to the condition. The condition becomes
again conditioned, and its condition is next to be discovered.
If the presupposition of Idealism is correct, and if no errors have been
made in the deduction, the last result, as containing all the conditions
of the first act, must contain the system of all necessary
representations, or the total experience;—a comparison, however, which
is not instituted in Philosophy itself, but only after that science has
finished its work.
For Idealism has not kept this experience in sight, as the preknown
object and result, which it should arrive at; in its course of
proceeding it knows nothing at all of experience, and does not look upon
it; it proceeds from its starting point according to its rules, careless
as to what the result of its investigations might turn out to be. The
right angle, from which it has to draw its straight line, is given to
it; is there any need of another point to which the line should be
drawn? Surely not; for all the points of its line are already given to
it with the angle. A certain number is given to you. You suppose that it
is the product of certain factors. All you have to do is to search for
the product of these factors according to the well-known rules. Whether
that product will agree with the given number, you will find out,
without any difficulty, as soon as you have obtained it. The given
number is the total experience; those factors are: the part of immediate
consciousness which was discovered, and the laws of Thinking; the
multiplication is the Philosophizing. Those who advise you, while
philosophizing, also to keep an eye upon experience, advise you to
change the factors a little, and to multiply falsely, so as to obtain by
all means corresponding numbers; a course of proceeding as dishonest as
it is shallow. In so far as those final results of Idealism are viewed
as such, as consequences of our reasoning, they are what is called the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account