The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910Various
History
The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910
Various
American-Irish Historical Society -- Periodicals; Ethnology -- United States -- Periodicals; Irish Americans -- Periodicals
“I collected myself for a last effort. I read the clause in the
Constitution against titles of nobility; showed that the spirit of it
was against not only granting titles by Congress but against the
permission to foreign potentates granting _any titles whatever_; that as
to kingly government, it was equally out of the question as a republican
government was guaranteed to every State in the Union; that they were
both equally forbidden fruit of the Constitution. I called the attention
of the House to the consequences that were likely to follow; that
gentleman seemed to court a rupture with the Lower House. The
Representatives had adopted the report [rejecting titles] and were this
day acting on it or according to the spirit of the report. We were
proposing a title. Our conduct would mark us to the world as actuated by
the spirit of dissension; and the characters of the [two] Houses would
be as aristocratic and democratical.”
IX.
“HIS ELECTIVE HIGHNESS.”
Finally the matter came to a vote and the report of the Title Committee,
conferring the title of “Elective Majesty” on Washington was rejected.
Then began the fight, for, at least, some kind of a title for the
President. Izard moved for the title of “Excellency,” but he withdrew
it, upon which Lee suggested “Highness” with some prefatory word such as
“Elective Highness.” Maclay records: “It was insisted that such a
dignified title would add greatly to the weight and authority of the
Government, both at home and abroad. I declared myself of a totally
different opinion; that at present it was impossible to add to the
respect entertained for General Washington; that if you gave him the
title of any foreign prince or potentate, a belief would follow that the
manners of that prince and his modes of government would be adopted by
the President. (Mr. Lee had, just before I got up, read over a list of
the titles of all the princes and potentates of the earth, marking where
the word ‘highness’ occurred. The Grand Turk had it, all the crown
princes of Germany had it, sons and daughters of crown heads, etc.) That
particularly ‘Elective Highness,’ which sounded nearly like ‘Electoral
Highness,’ would have a most ungrateful sound to many thousands of
industrious citizens who had fled from German oppression; that
‘Highness’ was part of the title of a prince or princess of the blood
and was often given to dukes; that it was degrading our President to
place him on a par with any prince of any blood in Europe, nor was there
one of them that could enter the list of true glory with him.”
X.
“ROYAL ETIQUETTE.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account