The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910Various
History
The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910
Various
American-Irish Historical Society -- Periodicals; Ethnology -- United States -- Periodicals; Irish Americans -- Periodicals
XIV.
“AFFECTATION OF SIMPLICITY.”
Vice-President Adams now put the question and the postponement was
carried; immediately after which Maclay offered a resolution for a
conference between the two Houses. It was carried and the committee
appointed. But now Ellsworth drew up another resolution in which the
differences between the two Houses were to be kept out of sight and to
proceed _de novo_ on a title for the President. “I did not enter into
the debate,” records Maclay, “but expressed my fear that the House of
Representatives would be irritated and would not meet us on that ground.
And, as if they meant to provoke the other House, they insisted that the
minute of rejection should go down with the appointment of the
committee. Little good can come of it thus circumstanced, more
especially as the old committee were reappointed,” namely, Ellsworth,
Johnson and Lee.
Monday, May 11, on motion of Lee, the subject of titles was postponed to
the following day, but under date of May 12 Maclay records: “The
business of considering the title, which was laid on the table, was
postponed to see what would be the result of the conference of the Joint
Committee on that subject.” Adams’s solicitude for titles was evident,
for when the Senate met, May 13, he reminded the members that the report
for the President’s title lay on the table. The Senate was informed by
Lee that the committee on titles had met in the Senate chamber but were
interrupted by the assembling of that body and had agreed to meet on the
following morning. Again, on May 14, the Vice-President “reminded us of
the title report” but the committee was out on it. In a short time,
however, they reported that the Lower House “had adhered in the
strictest manner to their former resolution,” which was against the
granting of titles of any kind.
This, indeed, was a heavy blow for the advocates of titles. Catching at
the last straw, Lee now moved that the Senate _de novo committee’s_
report in favor of titles be taken from the table and entered on the
files of the House. The spirit of his motion was that attention should
be paid to the usages of civilized nations in order to keep up a proper
respect to the President; that “affectation of simplicity would be
injurious”; that the Senate had decided in favor of titles but, in
deference to the expressed feelings of the Lower House, the Senate, “for
the present,” should address the President without title.
XV.
“YOUR HIGHNESS OF THE SENATE.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account