The Kingdom of God is Within You / Christianity and Patriotism / Miscellanies — John Shaqi
The Kingdom of God is Within You / Christianity and Patriotism / MiscellaniesTolstoy, Leo, graf
Religion
The Kingdom of God is Within You / Christianity and Patriotism / Miscellanies
Tolstoy, Leo, graf
Russian literature -- Translations into English
Noah, Moses, and the prophets taught that he who kills, maims, and
tortures his neighbours does evil. To resist such evil and destroy
it, the doer of evil is to be punished by death or maiming or some
personal injury. Insult is to be opposed to insult, murder to
murder, torture to torture, evil to evil. Thus taught Noah, Moses,
and the prophets. But Christ denies it all. "But I say unto you," it
says in the Gospel, "that ye resist not evil, resist not an insult
with an insult, but rather bear the repeated insult from the doer
of evil." What was authorized is prohibited. If we understand what
kind of resistance they taught, we clearly see what we are taught by
Christ's non-resistance.
_Q._ Did the ancients authorize the resistance of insult with insult?
_A._ Yes; but Jesus prohibited this. A Christian has under no
condition the right to deprive of life or to subject to insult him
who does evil to his neighbour.
_Q._ May a man kill or maim another in self-defence?
_A._ No.
_Q._ May he enter a court with a complaint, to have his insulter
punished?
_A._ No; for what he is doing through others, he is in reality doing
in his own person.
_Q._ May he fight with an army against enemies, or against domestic
rebels?
_A._ Of course not. He cannot take any part in war or warlike
preparations. He cannot use death-dealing arms. He cannot resist
injury with injury, no matter whether he be alone or with others,
through himself or through others.
_Q._ May he choose or fit out military men for the government?
_A._ He can do nothing of the kind, if he wishes to be true to
Christ's law.
_Q._ May he voluntarily give money, to aid the government, which is
supported by military forces, capital punishment, and violence in
general?
_A._ No, if the money is not intended for some special object, just
in itself, where the aim and means are good.
_Q._ May he pay taxes to such a government?
_A._ No; he must not voluntarily pay the taxes, but he must also
not resist their collection. The taxes imposed by the government
are collected independently of the will of the subjects. It is
impossible to resist the collection, without having recourse to
violence; but a Christian must not use violence, and so he must give
up his property to the violence which is exerted by the powers.
_Q._ May a Christian vote at elections and take part in a court or
in the government?
_A._ No; the participation in elections, in the court, or in the
government, is a participation in governmental violence.
_Q._ In what does the chief significance of the doctrine of
non-resistance consist?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account