The Knickerbocker, Vol. 22, No. 3, September 1843Various
General
The Knickerbocker, Vol. 22, No. 3, September 1843
Various
Periodicals
'The act ends with this seducing person getting drunk and
singing this delicious lay:
'No more dams I'll make for fish.
Nor fetch firing at requiring.
Nor scrape trencher, nor wash dish.
Ban, ban, Ca--Caliban,
Has a new master. Get a new man.'
'The third act represents Ferdinand at the eternal employment of
_fetching in wood_. Then follows a love-scene, which we omit.'
How many petty enemies had the 'myriad-minded SHAKSPEARE,' who would
have chuckled over this criticism, had it actually appeared in
his day! What nuts it would have been for that feeble reviler and
feebler rival of his, 'one HILL!' The summing up of the reviewer
is quite in keeping with the fine fancy and striking acumen
displayed in the detail of his criticism. 'The Tempest,' he says,
'shows us how ridiculous are those rules, to which writers have
hitherto subjected themselves, for the purpose, as they fondly
imagined, of giving interest to their dramas. It is to be hoped
that Mr. SHAKSPEARE's example will release them, in future, from
all obligation to pay any regard to probability in their incidents,
or to nature in their characters. It is evidently much more easy
to invent a jargon for witches, demons, and spirits, than to deal
with human passions and human affections; and it is clearly quite
unnecessary to diversify a play with pathetic incidents, when the
sleep which has hitherto been confined to the spectators is here
transferred to the persons of the drama. Writers need no longer
search for lofty subjects, which have been so absurdly deemed
requisite to tragedy, when every one can readily find a storm either
at sea or on shore. Many improvements will no doubt be made upon the
new system, and we may shortly expect to see tragedies upon a fall
of snow or a heavy shower of rain. 'The Tempest' fairly entitles
Mr. SHAKESPEARE to the honors due to a reformer of our poetry, and
if it produces as much profit as some of those plays in which he
has praised princes and traduced the people, we shall be convinced
that there are other persons beside Lapland conjurors who can make a
comfortable living upon contrary winds and wrecked vessels.'
Turn we now to GIFFORD's review of MILTON's 'Paradise Lost,' in
which the cut-and-slash style of that great critic, which was
'nothing if not personal,' is very faithfully portrayed. It opens as
follows:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account