=44. NOBILITAS INGEMINATA.= In a famous study (_Kleine Schriften_ I 1 ff.;
trans. _The Roman Nobility_ [1969]), Matthias Gelzer demonstrated that
the usual meaning of _nobilis_ was 'descended from a consul'. Cotta was
descended from a consul on both sides.
At _Met_ XIII 144-47 Ovid uses _nobilitas_ to mean 'descent from a god':
(Ulysses speaking) 'mihi Laertes pater est, Arcesius illi, / Iuppiter
huic ... est quoque _per matrem_ Cyllenius _addita_ nobis / _altera
nobilitas_: deus est in utroque parente!'.
=44. INGEMINATA.= A verbal echo of _EP_ I ii 1-2 (to Fabius Maximus)
'Maxime, qui tanti mensuram nominis imples, / et _geminas_ animi
_nobilitate_ genus'.
=46. ATQVE INTER TANTOS QVAE LEGERETVR ERAT.= This is the end of the
sentence that began at 5.
=46. INTER TANTOS.= Compare _EP_ III i 55-56 (Ovid has just compared
himself to Capaneus, Amphiaraus, Ulysses, and Philoctetes) 'si locus est
aliquis _tanta inter nomina_ paruis, / nos quoque conspicuos nostra
ruina facit'.
=47. SVMMOTVM= _codd_ SVBMOTVM _edd_. The assimilated _summ-_ is standard
in the manuscripts of Virgil and Lucretius, and should not be altered.
=47. PROSCINDERE= = 'revile, defame'. This seems to be the first instance
of the word in this sense; the other examples cited by _OLD_ _proscindo_
3 are Val Max V iii 3, Val Max VIII 5 2 'C. Flauium eadem lege accusatum
testis _proscidit_', Pliny _NH_ XXXIII 6, and Suet _Cal_ 30 2 'equestrem
ordinem ut scaenae harenaeque deuotum assidue _proscidit_'. The word
connects with _laceras_ in the first line of the poem, and with _neu
cineres sparge, cruente, meos_ in 48.
=49. OMNIA PERDIDIMVS.= The same phrase at _Met_ XIII 527-28 (Hecuba
speaking) '_omnia perdidimus_: superest cur uiuere tempus / in breue
sustineam proles gratissima matri'.
=49. TANTVMMODO= is a prose word. It occurs elsewhere in Ovid only at
_Fast_ III 361 'ortus erat summo _tantummodo_ margine Phoebus' and at
_Tr_ III vii 29-30 'pone, Perilla, metum; _tantummodo_ femina nulla /
neue uir a scriptis discat amare tuis'. Being a colloquial term, it is
found in satire (Hor _Sat_ I ix 54) and comedy (Ter _Ph_ 109).
=50. SENSVM MATERIAMQVE MALI.= 'An occasion for pain, and the ability to
feel it'. For _sensum_ compare _EP_ I ii 29-30 'felicem Nioben ... quae
posuit _sensum_ saxea facta _mali_ [_uar_ malis]' and _EP_ I ii 37
'uiuimus ut numquam _sensu_ careamus amaro'. For _materiam_ compare
_Her_ VII 34 'materiam curae praebeat ille meae!', _Met_ X 133-34 'ut
leuiter pro materiaque doleret / admonuit' and _EP_ I x 23-24 'dolores,
/ quorum materiam dat locus ipse mihi'.
=51-52. QVID IVVAT EXTINCTOS FERRVM DEMITTERE IN ARTVS? / NON HABET IN
NOBIS IAM NOVA PLAGA LOCVM.= I believe this distich is an interpolation
for the following reasons:
(1) Lines 49-50 form an effective ending, which 51-52 weaken. In 49-50
Ovid says that life is all that is left to him; and in 52 it is stated
that he is already wounded in every place possible. These statements are
contradictory.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account