The Law and Medical MenRogers, R. Vashon (Robert Vashon)
History
The Law and Medical Men
Rogers, R. Vashon (Robert Vashon)
Medical laws and legislation
But where the evidence showed that the patient’s own attorney prepared
the papers, that he had independent advice, and understood what he
was doing, and exercised his free will, and that the medical man had
long attended him, the Court refused to set aside the deed, although
the patient was eighty years of age [377]. And although a |141| gift
made to a physician may be voidable, because of his standing in a
confidential relation to the donor, a patient, yet, if after the
confidential relation has ceased to exist, the donor intentionally
elects to abide by the gift, and does, in fact, abide by it, it cannot
be impeached after his death, even if it is not proved that the patient
was aware that the gift was voidable at his election [378].
There is, of course, nothing in the relation of medical attendant and
patient which can prevent the one from entering into a contract with
the other, where the transaction proceeds openly and fairly, and the
relation of physician and patient has, in reality, no bearing upon
it [379]. In the case of a sale by a patient to a physician, where there
was no proof of inadequacy of price, the transaction was sustained [380].
A strong case must be made to set aside a will on the ground of undue
influence. Influence is not sufficient: there must be such a degree
of influence as deprives the testator of the proper mastery over
his faculties [381]. To invalidate a will, on the ground of undue
influence, it must be shown that it was practised with respect to the
will itself, or so contemporaneously with the will, or connected with
it, as by almost necessary presumption to affect it; and flattery
and obsequiousness, however degrading, will not constitute such an
undue influence as will affect the acts of a capable testatrix [382].
Many wills made in favour of medical men by their patients have been
sustained, although disputed, and that even in cases where the patients
have been aged, infirm women, with impaired minds [383]. |142|
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account