The Life & Letters of Peter Ilich TchaikovskyChaikovskii, Modest
General
The Life & Letters of Peter Ilich Tchaikovsky
Chaikovskii, Modest
Composers -- Russia -- Biography; Tchaikovsky, Peter Ilich, 1840-1893
“Yesterday was a very exciting day. In the morning at the Châtelet
Concert the performance of my _Tempest_ took place. The agonies I
endured are the best proof that a country life is the most
tolerable for me. What used to be a pleasure--the hearing of one
of my own works--has now become a source of misery. The evening
before I began to suffer from colic and nausea. My agitation
continued to grow _crescendo_ until the opening chords, and while
the work was proceeding I felt I should die of the pain in my
heart. It was not the fear of failure with the public, but because
lately the first hearing of all my works has brought me the
sharpest disappointment. Mendelssohn’s _Reformation_ symphony
preceded _The Tempest_, and all the time I was admiring this fine
masterpiece. I have not attained to the rank of a master. I still
write like a gifted young man from whom much is to be expected.
What surprised me chiefly was the fact that my orchestration
sounded so poor. Of course, my reason told me I was exaggerating my
own defects, but this was no great consolation. _The Tempest_ was
not badly played. The orchestra took pains, but showed no warmth of
enthusiasm. One member of the band (a ‘cellist) kept staring,
smiling, and nodding his head, as much as to say: ‘Excuse our
playing such an extraordinary work; it is not our fault; we are
ordered to play it, and we obey.’ After the last bars had died
away, there followed some feeble applause, mingled with two or
three audible hisses, at which the whole room broke out into
exclamations of ‘O! O!’ which were intended as a kindly protest
against the hisses. Then came silence. The whole business passed
over me without leaving any special bitterness. I was only vexed to
feel that _The Tempest_, which I have hitherto regarded as one of
my most brilliant works, is in reality so unimportant. I left the
room and, as the weather was very fine, took a two hours’ stroll.
On returning home I wrote a card to Colonne, telling him that I
could only remain another day in Paris, and could not therefore
call to thank him personally.
“I must soon leave Paris. I am reconciled to the failure of _The
Tempest_. I speak of it as a failure _to myself_, but I console
myself with the thought that after the opera and the Suite I shall
at last compose a fine symphonic work. And so, in all probability,
I shall strive for mastery until my last breath, without ever
attaining it. Something is lacking in me--I can feel it--but there
is nothing to be done.”
The _Gazette Musicale_ published Tchaikovsky’s letter to Colonne, which
ran as follows:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account