'... Continuing his corrections, Brahms did not confine himself to
remarks on the composition itself, but considered the handwriting
also worthy of his notice. He pointed out that I had not placed
crotchet under crotchet, and that this impaired the legibility of
the manuscript; he advised me to be particular to slur the groups
of notes with exactness.... "Look here," he said, fetching from the
next room Wagner's autograph score of "Tannhäuser," which he opened
at the long B major movement of the second act; "Wagner has taken
pains to place each of the five sharps exactly in its place on
_every_ line of _every_ page, and in spite of all this precision
the writing is easy and flowing. If _such_ a man can write so
neatly, you must do so too." He turned over the entire movement and
pointed reproachfully to almost every sharp. I felt continually
smaller, especially as Brahms talked himself into a kind of
didactic wrathfulness. I was struck completely dumb, however, when,
on my remarking that Wagner must be held chiefly responsible for
the confusion prevailing in the heads of us young people, Brahms
cried as though he had been stung, "_Nonsense_; the _misunderstood_
Wagner has done it. Those understand _nothing_ of the real Wagner
who are led astray by him. Wagner's is one of the clearest heads
that ever existed in the world!"'
That Brahms was aware that the resolution to compose an opera would
place him in a net of difficulties that might practically be summed up
in the one word 'Wagner' is no mere conjecture. Fräulein Anna Ettlinger,
an intimate friend of Levi and Allgeyer, who knew Brahms well both at
Carlsruhe and Munich, relates in an article on Levi, that Brahms
answered a question put to him in Munich in the course of the seventies,
as to why he had written no opera by saying, 'Beside Wagner it is
impossible.' It may fairly be concluded that Brahms, in the late
seventies, merely 'coquetted,' as Widmann expresses it, with the idea of
composing for the stage, though no doubt with considerable regret.[57]
It cannot be said that the subjects he proposed to Widmann appear happy,
but his suggestions must not be taken too seriously.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account