Republican resistance to this measure now ceased and the rôle of
opposition was taken up by the Democrats. Powell, of Kentucky, contended
that the power to suspend the writ of _habeas corpus_ was lodged in
Congress exclusively and could not be delegated to the President. He
raised the objection also that there was no definition of the phrase
"political offenses." Trumbull agreed to strike out that phrase
altogether, in which case the President would have the power to suspend
the writ for all offenses, and could determine for himself which ones
were political and which were non-political. As to the right of Congress
to delegate its own powers to the President in analogous cases, he cited
the power to borrow money, the power to grant letters of marque and
reprisal, and the power to call forth the militia, all of which were
lodged in Congress, but which Congress never exercised directly, but
only by delegating its powers to the Executive.
Senator Carlile, of Virginia, held that the writ of _habeas corpus_
ought never to be suspended in places where the courts were open.
Trumbull replied that if it were not suspended in those places it could
never be suspended at all, for if there were no courts open, the writ
itself could not be issued. Yet the Constitution clearly contemplated
the necessity of suspending it in certain conditions where it actually
existed.
February 23, 1863, Trumbull's substitute was agreed to by yeas 25, nays
12, and the bill was passed by 24 to 13. All of the negative votes,
except two, were cast by Democrats.
February 27, the Senate took up the Stevens House bill to indemnify the
President and adopted a substitute proposed by Trumbull. The substitute
was not adopted by the House, but a conference was asked for and agreed
to by the Senate. The conferees decided to consolidate into one act the
Indemnity Bill and the _Habeas Corpus_ Bill, which was still pending
between the two houses. The report of the Conference Committee was
presented to the Senate by Trumbull on March 2, one day before the end
of the Thirty-seventh Congress.
Except the financial bills, this was the most important measure of the
session, and the one about which the most heat had been engendered. On
the 24th of September, 1862, the President had proclaimed martial law
throughout the nation as to persons discouraging enlistments or
resisting the Conscription Act and had suspended the writ of _habeas
corpus_ as to such persons. On the 1st of January following, he had
issued the Emancipation Proclamation, of which he had given preliminary
notice one hundred days before. These measures were extremely
distasteful to the Democrats and especially so to those of the border
slave states. The pending measure was intended to condone all former
arbitrary arrests and to sanction an indefinite number in the future,
although providing for speedy trials.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account