Pasteur, Louis, 1822-1895; Scientists -- France -- Biography
Colin, however, returned to the subject, and at an Academy meeting of
July 9 said somewhat insolently, “I wish we could have seen the
bacteridia of that dead hen which M. Pasteur showed us without taking it
out of its cage, and which he took away intact instead of making us
witness the necropsy and microscopical examination.” “I will take no
notice,” said Pasteur at the following meeting, “of the malevolent
insinuations contained in that sentence, and only consider M. Colin’s
desire to hold in his hands the body of a hen dead of anthrax, full of
bacteridia. I will, therefore, ask M. Colin if he will accept such a hen
under the following condition: the necropsy and microscopic examination
shall be made by himself, in my presence, and in that of one of our
colleagues of this Academy, designated by himself or by this Academy,
and an official report shall be drawn up and signed by the persons
present. So shall it be well and duly stated that M. Colin’s
conclusions, in his paper of May 14, are null and void. The Academy will
understand my insistence in rejecting M. Colin’s superficial
contradictions.
“I say it here with no sham modesty: I have always considered that my
only right to a seat in this place is that given me by your great
kindness, for I have no medical or veterinary knowledge. I therefore
consider that I must be more scrupulously exact than any one else in the
presentations which I have the honour to make to you; I should promptly
lose all credit if I brought you erroneous or merely doubtful facts. If
ever I am mistaken, a thing which may happen to the most scrupulous, it
is because my good faith has been greatly surprised.
“On the other hand, I have come amongst you with a programme to follow
which demands accuracy at every step. I can tell you my programme in two
words: I have sought for twenty years, and I am still seeking,
spontaneous generation properly so called.
“If God permit, I shall seek for twenty years and more the spontaneous
generation of transmissible diseases.
“In these difficult researches, whilst sternly deprecating frivolous
contradiction, I only feel esteem and gratitude towards those who may
warn me if I should be in error.”
The Academy decided that the necropsy and microscopic examination of the
dead hen which Pasteur was to bring to Colin should take place in the
presence of a Commission composed of Pasteur, Colin, Davaine, Bouley,
and Vulpian. This Commission met on the following Saturday, July 20, in
the Council Chamber of the Academy of Medicine. M. Armand Moreau, a
member of the Academy, joined the five members present, partly out of
curiosity, and partly because he had special reasons for wishing to
speak to Pasteur after the meeting.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account