Bracciolini, Poggio, 1380-1459; Italy -- History -- 1268-1492
“Soon after my return from Baden to Constance, the cause of Jerome of
Prague, who was accused of heresy, came to a public hearing. The purport
of my present letter is to give you an account of this trial, which must
of necessity be a matter of considerable interest, both on account of
the importance of the subject, and the eloquence and learning of the
defendant. I must confess that I never saw any one who in pleading a
cause, especially a cause on the issue of which his own life depended,
approached nearer to that standard of ancient eloquence, which we so
much admire. It was astonishing to witness with what choice of words,
with what closeness of argument, with what confidence of countenance he
replied to his adversaries. So impressive was his peroration, that it is
a subject of great concern, that a man of so noble and excellent a genius
should have deviated into heresy. On this latter point however, I cannot
help entertaining some doubts. But far be it from me to take upon myself
to decide in so important a matter. I shall acquiesce in the opinion of
those who are wiser than myself.
“Do not however imagine that I intend to enter into the particulars of
this cause. I shall only touch upon the more remarkable and interesting
circumstances, which will be sufficient to give you an idea of the
learning of the man.
“Many things having been alleged against the prisoner as proofs of his
entertaining heretical notions, and the council being of opinion, that
the proof was sufficiently strong to warrant further investigation, it
was ordered that he should publicly answer to every particular of the
charge. He was accordingly brought before the council. But when he was
called upon to give in his answers, he for a long time refused so to
do; alleging, that he ought to be permitted to speak generally in his
defence, before he replied to the false imputations of his adversaries.
This indulgence was however denied him. Upon which, standing up in the
midst of the assembly—What gross injustice is this! exclaimed he, that
though for the space of three hundred and forty days, which I have spent
in filth and fetters, deprived of every comfort, in prisons situated at
the most remote distances from each other, you have been continually
listening to my adversaries and slanderers, you will not hear me for a
single hour! The consequence of this is, that while on the one hand,
every one’s ears are open to them, and they have for so long a time been
attempting to persuade you that I am a heretic, an enemy of the true
faith, a persecutor of the clergy; and on the other hand, I am deprived
of every opportunity of defending myself; you have prejudged my cause,
and have in your own minds condemned me, before you could possibly
become acquainted with my principles. But, says he, you are not Gods,
but men, not immortals, but mortals, liable to error, and subject to
imperfection. We are taught to believe that this assembly contains the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account