Lincoln was burning with jealousy. He believed himself to be
Douglas' full equal in mental endowment. Fortune, he thought, with
a tinge of bitterness, had dealt with them most unequally, clothing
his rival with the glory of a world-renowned statesman, and leaving
him to waste his powers on the obscure quarrels of litigious clients
in a small town. He yearned for the opportunity to measure himself
with the great Senator on a conspicuous stage.
This series of debates was a rare piece of strategy on Lincoln's
part. Douglas had so long been wrapped in his senatorial toga
that his greatness had become exaggerated to the popular mind of
Illinois; while Lincoln had been a plain, modest lawyer, moving
among the people in the daily round of routine life. The dogmatic
statement of the great Senator carried more weight than the
profoundest argument of the clearest demonstration of the country
lawyer. But these debates brought them to a common level. They
measured their intellectual strength in the presence of the people,
with all official trappings laid aside; and while no one could well
be disappointed in Douglas' strength, the whole country was amazed
at the unexpected power of Lincoln.
There were disadvantages to Douglas in this mode of combat. He
must sacrifice the glamour of senatorial dignity and enter the arena
on equal footing with his antagonist. He was a brilliant debater.
"In the whole field of American politics no man has equaled him
in the expedients and strategy of debate. * * * He was tireless,
ubiquitous, unseizable. It would have been as easy to hold
a globule of mercury under the finger's tip as to fasten him to a
point he desired to evade. * * * In spirit he was alert, combative,
aggressive; in manner patronizing and arrogant by turns." But
he had to meet in argument a man of imperturbably temper, who had
thought deeply on the great questions of the time, who by unerring
instinct could lay his finger on every flaw in his chain of
reasoning, could rise to heights of eloquence beyond the reach of
his unimaginative mind and pour out streams of quaint humor that
must have filled him with despair.
So great was the interest of the people in this extraordinary contest
that it was found impossible to hold the meetings in halls. They
were held during the warm autumn days in the open air, where the
crowds, numbering from five to twenty thousand, struggled to get
within range of the speakers' voices.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account